The Biggest Misconception in Physics
Channel:Veritasium · Length:27:39 · Published:2025-04-14 · Views:14369241
Summary
Veritasium explores why energy is not conserved in general relativity, using Emmy Noether's theorem linking symmetries to conservation laws. Physicists interviewed explain energy loss in an expanding universe.
Why HN recommends it
Recommended as high-quality physics communication and as an introduction to Noether and energy non-conservation in cosmology.
thought wow this is good. Much better than the physics lectures I had at Cambridge Uni. — HN, 2025
Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication
Subtitles (excerpt)
- Imagine you are an astronaut out drifting in deep space when you throw a rock as hard as you can. What's gonna happen to that rock? Well, you would think that it would continue with constant velocity in a straight line. That's just Newton's first law. But what actually happens is it eventually slows down and stops. So why does this happen? Where did all the rock's energy go? (pensive orchestral music) At the turn of the 20th century, the problem of energy conservation baffled some of the greatest minds, including Albert Einstein. Einstein came up with a possible solution, but then a little-known unpaid mathematician named Emmy Noether proved he was wrong. And in doing so, she created a whole new paradigm for physics, one that underlies all of particle physics and explains why anything is conserved. (gentle inquisitive music) It all started in 1915 at the University of Gottingen, where Einstein was giving six lectures on his new theory of gravity. What would become the general theory of relativity. The lectures were well received, but Einstein hadn't yet settled on the final form of the field equations. One problem he was facing was how to show that total energy was conserved in his new theory.
On Hacker News
Rather than turning to shit, I think the internet may be getting more diverse stuff in general. More good stuff and more shit. As an example of anti-shit I watched Veritasium "The Biggest Misconception in Physics" [VIDEO] yesterday and thought wow this is good. Much better than the physics lectures I had at Cambridge Uni. — tim333, 2025-08
The typical example people use to illustrate that energy isn't conserved is that photons get red-shifted and lose energy in an expanding universe. See this excellent Veritasium video [0]. But there's a much more striking example that highlights just how badly energy conservation can be violated. It's called cosmic inflation. General relativity predicts that if empty space in a 'false vacuum' stat… — qnleigh, 2025-12
reminds me of this video I found the other day [VIDEO] if I'm understanding correctly the implications of Emily Noether's work, its an absolute travesty that she isn't famous in the same breath as Einstein and Feynman. Yet this video was the first time I had even heard of her. — cultofmetatron, 2025-04
The most recent Veritasium video touched on this — Emmy Noether worked under Hilbert and made significant contributions to general relativity, worked at University of Göttingen (Jewish, and first woman professor) until 1933. [VIDEO] — ccorcos, 2025-04
> Energy and momentum are always conserved in EVERY physical process. Veritasium recently claimed otherwise [VIDEO] — dataflow, 2025-07
Related videos
- Will AI outsmart human intelligence? - with 'Godfather of AI' Geoffrey Hinton · The Royal Institution · 47:15
- Joe Rogan Experience #2255 - Mark Zuckerberg · PowerfulJRE · 2:50:36
- Y Combinator's Paul Graham sits down with Jason at LAUNCH Festival 2014 · This Week in Startups · 55:15
- Hans Rosling's 200 Countries, 200 Years, 4 Minutes - The Joy of Stats - BBC · BBC · 4:47
- RailsConf 2016 - Rails to Phoenix by Brian Cardarella · Confreaks · 28:33
- Steve Jobs, "Computers are like a bicycle for our minds." - Michael Lawrence Films · Michael Lawrence · 1:39
- Secret Life Of Machines 104 The Washing Machine · Retrotv · 25:51
- Feynman: Mathematicians versus Physicists · TehPhysicalist · 9:46
- Why The World Relies On ASML For Machines That Print Chips · CNBC · 18:39
- Drone Delivery Was Supposed to be the Future. What Went Wrong? · Wendover Productions · 18:39
- Amputee Makes History with APL’s Modular Prosthetic Limb · Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Laboratory · 4:33
- Neom - The Line - The Rise and Fall of Saudi Arabia's Linear City. · Patrick Boyle · 32:54
- The Best Country in the World for Drivers · Not Just Bikes · 15:48
- The Most Powerful Computers You've Never Heard Of · Veritasium · 20:12
- Future Computers Will Be Radically Different (Analog Computing) · Veritasium · 21:42
- What Everyone Gets Wrong About Gravity · Veritasium · 17:33
- The Simple Path to Wealth | JL Collins | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 57:44