No, The Tank Is Not Dead.
Channel:The Chieftain · Length:31:36 · Published:2022-04-16 · Views:943452
Summary
Armor expert The Chieftain explains why tanks still have a place on the modern battlefield despite drones and guided weapons. He responds to the 'tank is dead' debate, noting that tanks have been declared dead repeatedly since 1919.
Why HN recommends it
Pointed to as an authoritative answer, from a former Abrams commander and tank historian, to claims that tanks are obsolete.
I'd recommend this video by a former Abrams commander and tank historian who presents this argument far better than I can. — HN, 2022
Subtitles (excerpt)
greetings all about two weeks back a chap called perron put out a very good video asking if now finally is the time that the atgm has managed to end the tank it's a very well argued and presented video i've put a link down below in case you've not yet seen it as i mentioned in the last video about application of critical thinking i firmly believe that no it is not the end of the tank and since then others to include bernhardt over on military history visualize have also put out observations that the death of the tank has been declared many times in the past and i'll put a link to that below as well now in fairness to peru he is very upfront about not coming to the conclusion that tanks are now only so much metal waiting to be sent to the scrap heap but he makes a very definite argument that economics are in favor of missiles over anything but the most modern tanks and the jury is out on the latter so this is not a counter-argument video i have no huge points of disagreement with him some kind of quibbles but generally speaking his arguments are well supported instead i'm going to try to explain why even though anti-tank missiles are getting better and drones and sense of fused artillery are a newer threat there are
On Hacker News
> currently completely overmatched by anti-tank weapons The Chieftan disagrees with you. [VIDEO] I suspect he has more practical and theoretical knowledge on the topic than the sum total of all posters on this thread. — mellavora, 2022-11
Against an enemy with signal jamming capability remote operation is not a given. Plus tanks communicate in real time with infantry/other elements. The lag introduced by remote operation/communication would be a serious hindrance even if everything was working, which it often isn't. Tanks have to respond in real time, they don't have the luxury of seconds of delay like say an orbiting drone. There… — scottLobster, 2022-11
I really don't think that's a good comparison, cavalry didn't just fall from grace because they became easily slaughtered by infantry, they stopped being used because their role became irrelevant and were replaced. The role tanks play has not become irrelevant and while they aren't as survivable as they used to be they aren't nearly as vulnerable as clips from UA seem to imply. I'd recommend this… — some_random, 2022-06
Yes it does. See "The Chieftain: No, The Tank Is Not Dead" [VIDEO] TLDW: Tank has a task on a battlefield and fact that you can easily kill it won't take that task away. Same goes for infantry and they are not going away either. On the other hand we don't see battleships anymore, because big guns were replaced by precise missiles with much more range. — breadloaf, 2022-06
An armor officer can answer this better than I can: [VIDEO] If you're watching the videos from Ukraine - the Russians are pretty much doing it all wrong. You do not send tanks into cities unless they're following infantry who are clearing houses & rooftops. You do not leave your tanks parked in a nice neat line on a country road. When your unit comes under fire, you do not just sit there. Why are… — chiph, 2022-05
Related videos
- Johnny Cash - Hurt · JohnnyCashVEVO · 3:48
- The Big Short (2015) - FrontPoint Partners' investigation in Florida & first trade [HD 1080p] · Extractor · 7:25
- The Biggest Chemical Coverup In History · Veritasium · 54:08
- The Antique Toaster that's Better than Yours · Technology Connections · 18:28
- Margin Call (2011) - Senior Partners Emergency Meeting [HD 1080p] (Re-Upload / Audio Fixed) · Extractor · 9:48
- The Century of the Self - Part 1: "Happiness Machines" · JustAdamCurtis · 58:46
- Why Russia Can’t Replace TSMC · Asianometry · 16:06
- Mechanical Computer (All Parts) - Basic Mechanisms In Fire Control Computers · Excelsior10000 · 41:53
- U.S. NAVY BASIC MECHANISMS OF FIRE CONTROL COMPUTERS MECHANICAL COMPUTER INSTRUCTIONAL FILM 27794 · PeriscopeFilm · 19:42
- The Secret War · Sergio IQ · 4:55:45
- This Is What Winning Looks Like (Full Length) · VICE · 1:29:10
- Tiedustelueverstin arvio Venäjästä | 3.12.2018 · fin_topsu · 1:00:22
- Secret History of Silicon Valley · Computer History Museum · 1:02:47
- David Fravor: UFOs, Aliens, Fighter Jets, and Aerospace Engineering | Lex Fridman Podcast #122 · Lex Fridman · 3:56:24
- The Battle of Midway 1942: Told from the Japanese Perspective (1/3) · Montemayor · 41:46
- Threads (1984) ORIGINAL TRAILER [HD 1080p] · HD Retro Trailers · 2:23