The medical test paradox, and redesigning Bayes' rule

Channel:3Blue1Brown · Length:21:13 · Published:2020-12-22 · Views:1434651

Watch on YouTube

Summary

3Blue1Brown explains why positive results on accurate medical tests are often false positives, and reframes Bayes' rule using likelihood ratios (Bayes factors) to update odds. It uses visual examples to make the reasoning intuitive.

Why HN recommends it

HN's go-to link whenever Bayesian reasoning, base rates or imperfect tests come up.

is a brilliant introduction to the concept — HN, 2021

Probability & game theory · Recreational & visual math

Subtitles (excerpt)

Some of you may have heard this paradoxical fact about medical tests. It's very commonly used to introduce the topic of Bayes' rule in probability. The paradox is that you could take a test which is highly accurate, in the sense that it gives correct results to a large majority of the people taking it. And yet, under the right circumstances, when assessing the probability that your particular test result is correct, you can still land on a very low number, arbitrarily low, in fact. In short, an accurate test is not necessarily a very predictive test. Now when people think about math and formulas, they don't often think of it as a design process. I mean, maybe in the case of notation it's easy to see that different choices are possible, but when it comes to the structure of the formulas themselves and how we use them, that's something that people typically view as fixed. In this video, you and I will dig into this paradox, but instead of using it to talk about the usual version of Bayes' rule, I'd like to motivate an alternate version, an alternate design choice. Now, what's up on the screen now is a little bit abstract, which makes it difficult to justify that there really is a substantive difference here,

On Hacker News

I agree that this is definitely a trend, so I feel like highlighting a great example of educational content that is very dense, concise, and with just a touch of whimsy: 3Blue1Brown on Youtube[0]. He has been doing math education videos on YouTube for years. I just watched his latest video on the medical test paradox and redesigning the Bayes rule to address it[1]. All his videos are absolutely p… — drewmate, 2020-12
I really like this video [1] from 3blue1brown, where he proposes to think about significance as a way to update the probability. One positive test (or in this analog a study) updates the probability by X % and thus you nearly always need more tests (or studies) for a 'meaningful' judgment. [1] [VIDEO] — V__, 2025-08
3Blue1Brown explains it well. [VIDEO] If the population who do _not_ actually have serious cancer is orders of magnitudes larger than those who do then there will be far more people in the false positive group than the true positive group and thus the vast majority of operations will be unnecessary. — andersrs, 2024-01
Almost no tests in existence can confirm or deny particular infection. Think of them (and symptoms) more as odds updater. If you have 20 minutes to spare this video [0] by 3 Blue 1 Brown is a brilliant introduction to the concept. [0] [VIDEO] — kilotaras, 2021-01
Usually the detectors are only called in once a basic "smell test" has failed. Those tests are imperfect, yes, but Bayesian probability tells us how to work out the rest. I have 0 trouble believing that the prior probability of an unscrupulous individual offloading an unpleasant and perceived-as-just-ceremonial duty to the "thinking machine" is around 20%. See: [VIDEO] — conartist6, 2025-11

Related videos