Richard Feynman - Names Don't Constitute Knowledge

Channel:Caitlin Spies · Length:2:06 · Published:2014-09-17 · Views:110763

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short excerpt from a 1973 Yorkshire TV film in which Richard Feynman explains that knowing the name of something is not the same as knowing it.

Why HN recommends it

Shared to end arguments over definitions and terminology, and as a reminder that memorizing names is not understanding.

when people start quibbling over words I like to point them to this feynman video. — HN, 2019

Fundamental physics · Education & learning · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

Feynman is in the forefront of one of the oldest and most intriguing games of hide and seek in science – finding the ultimate constituents of the world. In this search Feynman is a celebrated maverick who was encouraged by his father, who was a New York clothing salesman, to confront conventional wisdom. One Sunday all the kids were walking in little parties with their fathers in the woods. The next Monday we were playing in a field, and a kid said to me, "What's that bird? Do you know the name of that bird?" I said, "I haven't the slightest idea." He said, "Well, it is a brown‑throated thrush." He said, "Your father doesn't teach you anything." But my father had already taught me about the names of birds. Once we walked, and he said, "That is a brown-throated thrush. In German it is called the Pfleegel flügel. In Chinese it is called Keewontong. In Japanese a Towhatowharra, and so on. And when you know all the names of that bird in every language, you know nothing, but absolutely nothing, about the bird." And then we would go on and talk about the pecking and the feathers. So I had learned already that names don't constitute knowledge. Of course that has caused me a certain amount of trouble since because

On Hacker News

[VIDEO] I don't care what you call it, if person A starts mistreating person B and person B knows how to deal with these situations, person A will quickly stop mistreating person B. Your argument here appears to be that bullying if person A doesn't eventually fight back. I don't agree with that, but I'm not willing to argue over the names of things. — P5fRxh5kUvp2th, 2022-12
Sorry, I'm not reading all of that. I stopped at the second paragraph. The answer to the question doesn't actually matter, not to you, and not to me. It's a ploy to try and confound the conversation. If you and the other poster really feel it needs to be defined, then define cancelled as "the thing that happened to Dorian Abbot". boom, you're done. It now has a definition, tautological, but valid… — P5fRxh5kUvp2th, 2022-12
Sure, if you find the phrase "common sense" to be less offensive than "blind faith", but in this case they mean the same thing. [VIDEO] — P5fRxh5kUvp2th, 2022-12
when people start quibbling over words I like to point them to this feynman video. [VIDEO] The idea that risk isn't a part of the discussion about why a company is laying off 40% of its work force doesn't seem like it has much merit. The responses made sense, and they've been explained to you. You're just casting about trying to come up with some way to dismiss the other persons point while intel… — celticmusic, 2019-10
> Do you know any other examples [VIDEO] Where "complex numbers" is Chinese, "imaginary numbers" is German, and "2D numbers" is English in this analogy. — vinchuco, 2018-08

Related videos