The Problem With Facebook

Channel:2veritasium · Length:6:59 · Published:2014-01-14 · Views:3130291

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Veritasium's Derek Muller argues that Facebook's business model works against pages and creators, because it charges them to reach the audiences they built. He explains how filtering and paid promotion undermine the value of likes.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it, with its follow-up, as an exposé of fake likes and bot activity, and as a warning before spending on Facebook ads.

before you waste any money, watch these two videos — HN, 2014

Internet culture & memes · Product, marketing & sales · Tech industry & business models

Subtitles (excerpt)

The problem with Facebook is that it's keeping things from you. You don't see most of what is posted by your friends or the pages you follow. Now pages can be business or they can be individual creators like I freaking love science or my own page, Veritasium. When you post something on your personal page, it only goes to a small fraction of your friends. Now if they like it and engage with it will be spread to more of them, but if they don't the post basically stops there and the number of people your post reached is never revealed to you. Now imagine what this does to newsfeeds. Friends and family and pages that you don't actively engage with will disappear over time. This usually means that people you disagree with will vanish, leaving you with a newsfeed that's effectively an echo chamber of self-affirming views, the things you already think and believe. And don't you thinks it's possible to see a post and find it interesting without having the need to actually 'like' it or comment on it? I mean, it seems weird that you need to put out there every view, you need to make that an active choice. You know what posts people like most of all? It's babies and weddings. Does this newsfeed look familiar? Now Facebook would argue this filtering is

On Hacker News

for a fantastic expose of how facebook is riddled with fraud and bots, check out veritasium's two videos: facebook fraud [LINK] the problem with facebook [VIDEO] — lingben, 2017-04
for those interested in this topic these two excellent videos from veritasium corroborate this article and go beyond to explain the stark implications for facebook's business model: facebook fraud: [LINK] the problem with facebook: [VIDEO] > From January 2013 to February 2014, a global team of researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Software Systems, Microsoft’s and AT&T’s research labs, as… — lingben, 2015-04
facebook ads are junk and have been proven to be so before you waste any money, watch these two videos: [LINK] [VIDEO] — lingben, 2014-09
If you haven't yet watched Derek's earlier video about "the problem with facebook", you should: [VIDEO] because in it he lays bare several fundamental structural issues about facebook which 99% people don't realize. Well worth the watch. Unless fb changes drastically, it will die a surprisingly fast death. — lingben, 2014-02
Derek Muller burned money on Facebook ads, and did an analysis showing that their metrics are flat-out horseshit. Definitely have a watch if you're considering spending on Facebook. [VIDEO] — vacri, 2016-09

Related videos