string theory lied to us and now science communication is hard

Channel:Angela Collier · Length:52:11 · Published:2023-04-21 · Views:1466067

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Physicist Angela Collier's roughly hour-long video on how string theory was hyped to the public and what that did to science communication. She traces the history of the theory as a narrative and argues it is interesting but was oversold.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as an engaging critique of string theory hype and its effect on public trust in physics, and often cited alongside Peter Woit's writing.

while the video is nearly an hour long, it feels much shorter and is well worth watching — HN, 2024

Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

this is a video about string theory and how it dominated science and physics media for like 30 years and as there are direct results of that science communication is really hard now because they lied to us they lied to us for 30 years and now we have to pick up the pieces and I don't want to talk about string theory I don't want to talk about the science the math all the stuff involved in string theory I want to talk about the public response if you want to learn String Theory you can just go buy a textbook like this one this guy's a big guy in string theory he can teach it to you it's fine I want to talk about the public response and the duty we have as professional researchers to communicate science accurately and to distract me from doing the science I I'm gonna play a game while I talk and I've never recorded a video in a single sitting so I hope it goes okay um so to talk about String Theory we have to we have to describe it we have to talk about the science like a little bit I'm playing as normal don't judge me um so String Theory first came out in like the 50s the 60s there was a problem with protons and neutrons when we started hitting them with stuff protons and neutrons started acting like they had shape like they had structure like rather than acting

On Hacker News

I just wanted to second this recommendation - while the video is nearly an hour long, it feels much shorter and is well worth watching: [VIDEO] — sockmeistr, 2024-03
This [1] is a fantastic refutation of string theory in that the string theorists have taken more than their fair share of research dollars and public consciousness and that it's time for other branches of physics to get the funding. With limited resources, if you don't context switch, you starve everything else. [1] [VIDEO] — echelon, 2024-02
not a physicist but this video by Angela Collier is a fun watch: “string theory lied to us and now science communication is hard. [VIDEO] — carrozo, 2026-01
Exactly. Consistently untestable and unfalsifiable claims for decades has to be seriously questioned at some point, and I think we're well beyond that point. This is especially true for string theory. I'm particularly fond of how Angela Collier laid out the timeline of string theory in her video on it[0] as well as the consequences that science communication is now facing as a result. [0] = [VIDE… — Shawnecy, 2024-10
I’ve found this explainer by Angela Collier super helpful in understanding the current state of string theory. [VIDEO] I was a gigantic pop science fan and read The Elegant Universe when I was approximately 13 and am excited it’s still being read even if it’s not necessarily true about our universe. It’s got the inspiration and excitement part that’s all I really needed as a kid. — johnkpaul, 2024-08

Related videos