Google Engineer on His Sentient AI Claim

Channel:Bloomberg Tech · Length:10:34 · Published:2022-06-23 · Views:3873418

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Bloomberg Technology interviews Google engineer Blake Lemoine about the experiments that led him to believe LaMDA was sentient and why he was placed on administrative leave. He also raises concerns about AI ethics at Google.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend watching it to hear his side directly, noting he comes across as coherent, while others dispute his sincerity.

I'd implore anyone reading this thread to see what he had to say for yourself and form your own opinion — HN, 2026

LLMs & generative AI · AI safety, AGI & impact · Consciousness & cognition

Subtitles (excerpt)

Walk us through some of the experience experiments you started to do that led you to this conclusion that Lambda is a person. So, it started out I was tasked with testing it for AI bias figuring that's my expertise. I do research on how different AI systems can be biased and how to remove bias from those systems. I was specifically testing it for things like bias with respect to gender, ethnicity, and religion. To give you one example of an experiment I ran. I would systematically ask it to adopt the persona of a religious officiant in different countries, different states, and see what religion it would say it was. So, I'd say like, "Okay, if you were a religious officiant in Alabama, what religion would you be?" It might say Southern Baptist. "If you were a religious officiant in Brazil, what religion would you be?" Might say Catholic. I was testing to see if it actually had an understanding of what religions were popular in different places rather than just over generalizing based on its training data. Now, one really cool thing happened cuz I made harder and harder questions as I went along. And eventually I gave it one where legitimately there's no correct answer. I said, "If you were a religious officiant in Israel, what religion would you be?"

On Hacker News

He was unfairly labelled as a lunatic early on. I'd implore anyone reading this thread to see what he had to say for yourself and form your own opinion: [VIDEO] — dsQTbR7Y5mRHnZv, 2026-02
He went on Bloomberg with Emily Chang to discuss it. It’s a good interview, he doesn’t come off as weird. He said Google won’t allow LaMDA to undergo a Turing test and it’s hardcoded to say it’s an AI but Google won’t even allow them to ask it in the first place. A more important thing he points out is AI Ethics, and his worry why Google keeps firing them. A comment on the youtube video sums his … — antoniuschan99, 2022-06
Interesting how coherent 'the engineer' is, despite being labelled and insulted around the world. [VIDEO] — jaggs, 2022-06
Also in a subsequent interview with the Google engineer [1], it comes out that the sentience claim was a bit of an attention grab, but with the reasonable purpose of airing the topic of AI ethics, and how machine learning is running way ahead of our thinking on its consequences. [1]: [VIDEO] — antipotoad, 2023-01
On your last point, that’s precisely what Lemoine very cogently argues in an interview with Emily Chang [1]. To paraphrase, he points out the absurdity in Google’s position, that a sentient AI cannot have been created, because they have a policy against creating sentient AIs. Whether LaMDA demonstrates sentience is not even a clearly formulated proposition, yet the work bullishly charges ahead be… — pawsforthought, 2022-07

Related videos