Risking My Life To Settle A Physics Debate

Channel:Veritasium · Length:21:37 · Published:2021-05-29 · Views:12384788

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Veritasium investigates whether a wind-powered vehicle can travel directly downwind faster than the wind, driving the Blackbird craft himself. The video explains the physics behind a claim some physics professors dispute.

Why HN recommends it

Frequently linked whenever wind-powered vehicles come up, as the clearest visual explanation of how the craft works.

The visual that made it click for me was at 18:54 in the original video — HN, 2021

Fundamental physics · Everyday physics & science demos · Renewables, batteries & storage

Subtitles (excerpt)

This propeller craft was built to settle a physics debate because what its creators claim it can do is so counterintuitive that it seems to violate the law of conservation of energy. So I've come here to drive it myself and see if it really works. And is it safe? It feels makeshift. I'm not gonna lie. I need some wind. Give me a gust. It's a little unbalanced. Isn't it? Slow it down, Derek! Pull tack, pull tack! This video was sponsored by Kiwico, more about them at the end of the show. I've come to El Mirage, a dry lakebed, a couple hours from Los Angeles to race a one of a kind propeller craft. It's called Blackbird. And I'm here with its inventor, Rick - Howdy! And the current owner, Neil. It all started with a brain teaser: Can any wind-powered vehicle go directly downwind faster than the wind itself? If you've got a sail boat and you're sailing it straight down, wind. - Yeah. As soon as that sailboat is going the same speed as the wind, then there is no more wind. That is correct. You can't push the sailboat. So sailboats can't just go downwind faster than the wind. Not straight downwind. -Not straight downwind? Not direct downwind. Imagine a boat floating in the water. As the wind picks up, it pushes the sail, accelerating the boat.

On Hacker News

Derek from the YouTube channel Veritasium made two interesting videos about this vehicle. [VIDEO] [LINK] They go into some nice detail about why the physics works out the way it does. — TimSchumann, 2022-07
If you believe that sailboats can beat a drifting balloon downwind by zigzagging, then there is a very good explanation in the original Veritasium video that shows that this is essentially the same thing. Here's a link to the section of the video with that explanation [1]. Watch about 2 or 3 minutes starting there and it becomes clear. [1] [VIDEO] — tzs, 2021-08
I thought the video below provided a good explanation for why this works. The physics are similar to those of a single sailboat going faster than the wind. Imagine two sailboats on a cylindrical ocean on diagonal tacks, on opposite poles, and rotating around the core with rods connecting them to the core. Now you have a propeller. :) [VIDEO] — theli0nheart, 2021-08
The visual that made it click for me was at 18:54 in the original video[0]. It shows the air hitting the propeller losing kinetic energy which becomes the energy ultimately making the vehicle go. I also don't know how you can watch the treadmill video and doubt it after seeing it go up the treadmill unless you believed it was a complete hoax. [0] [VIDEO] — karmakaze, 2021-07
Original video triggering the bet for context: [VIDEO] Video discussing the bet and going over criticism: [LINK] Veritasium is a great YouTube channel. — kinjba11, 2021-07

Related videos