Napoleon's greatest foe

Channel:Lindybeige · Length:57:22 · Published:2018-01-25 · Views:1727215

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Lindybeige's long video on Napoleon's most effective opponent, Sir Sidney Smith, with plenty of detail on Napoleon's misdeeds along the way.

Why HN recommends it

Cited by commenters as a source of examples of Napoleon's cruelty and poor decisions.

World history · Military history & warfare

Subtitles (excerpt)

of all the people who did the world good by combating Napoleon Bonaparte and thwarting his ambitions who do you think did the most good well you could say what it's got to be surely the iron Duke could you go Ellington right cause he defeated them at Waterloo Wow maybe not Oh some of you might say I'll do it'll be a Russian general who threw him back from Moscow and the other retreat from Moscow and the destruction of the Grand Army is it that no possibly not aren't you mad aren't you of course it's Nelson isn't he because if Nelson hadn't smashed and Napoleon's for the combined Spanish and French fleets at Trafalgar and then Napoleon would have had so many more options around the Mediterranean around the rest well yes it's Nelson of course you know the column in in London and everything well all of those people are candidates but in the opinion of Napoleon himself it was someone that you perhaps haven't even heard of Sydney Smith later sir Sydney Smith all right he was born William Smith but never mind eat he used his middle name Sydney Smith and I believe this man deserves more recognition and so I'm making this video which has been sponsored by audible more of them later now I won't go into all the details of his

On Hacker News

It's not just the extreme left that doesn't like Napoleon. [VIDEO] > relevant part starts at about 16 minutes, all lindy really does is point out how absolutely horrible Napoleon actually was. — eru, 2021-09
[VIDEO] This video is full of good reasons why Napoleon was not a good person, see 24:30 for my personal favorite. — JoeyBananas, 2021-05
Are you demanding easy answers? There aren't any. The goal is deterrence, but deterrence doesn't work if you don't have a credible threat, which means that you have to have the credible threat, and a sufficiently insane opponent may call you on it. It's the reason why China going to a dictatorship is scary... the details of the dictatorship are irrelevant, the mere fact that one man will be in ch… — jerf, 2018-03

Related videos