Ramanujan: Making sense of 1+2+3+... = -1/12 and Co.
Channel:Mathologer · Length:34:24 · Published:2016-04-22 · Views:3586950
Summary
Mathologer examines how identities like 1+2+3+... = -1/12 arise in Ramanujan's work, starting from his 1913 letter to Hardy. The video explains the rules for summing infinite series and why such results are meaningful but not naive sums.
Why HN recommends it
Recommended as a careful, honest treatment of the -1/12 claim, often preferred over flashier videos.
If you have half an hour to spare, I highly recommend to watch — HN, 2019
Pure mathematics · Recreational & visual math
Subtitles (excerpt)
A lot of you will be familiar with this strange identity here: 1+2+3+ ... is equal to -1/12. Now when you think about it this looks totally insane because what we're doing here on the left side is we are adding larger and larger positive values, infinitely many of them, so if anything this left should add up to plus infinity. And not to negative 1/12. Most people who look at this for the first time think that this is just nonsense. Except it comes up in a very very famous letter in mathematics. A letter that was written by this guy down there Srinivasa Ramanujan in 1913. It was addressed to G.H. Hardy in Cambridge, UK. one of the most famous mathematicians at the time. Now a lot of people have heard about this letter but have not seen it. So I thought I show it to you. Ok, so here is the letter. It is a long letter and it's basically lots and lots and lots of theorems, mathematical theorems, enumeration of lots of theorems that Ramanujan says he's found and the most remarkable thing about this is that he has no real former mathematical training unlike Hardy. And so a lot of these things are pretty amazing and towards the end of the letter well this strange identity here comes up, and a couple of similarly strange
On Hacker News
It's more complicated. The lie is using the same symbol for the usual summation and the extended version of the summations. We all agree about the value of a finite summation. We all agree about the value of a sum when the summation is absolutely convergent. We all (almost) agree when the summation converges, but the convergence is not absolute. This is the standard definition that is used in a c… — gus_massa, 2019-08
Not sure if this is what you want, but I like: The post of Mathologer about 1+2+3+...=-1/12 , probably [VIDEO] The post of Minute Physics about the Higgs Boson , probably [LINK] — gus_massa, 2024-09
The result isn't owed to the zeta function. For example, Ramanujan derived it by relating the series to the product of two infinite polynomials, (1 - x + x² - x³ + ...) × (1 - x + x² - x³ + ...). (Ok, it's the square of one infinite polynomial.) Do that multiplication and you'll find the result is (1 - 2x + 3x² - 4x⁴ + ...). So the sum of the sequence of coefficients {1, -2, 3, -4, ...} is taken … — thaumasiotes, 2023-12
I agree that most videos in YouTube simplify the problem too much or are just wrong. My recommendations anyway: * Mathologer: " Ramanujan: Making sense of 1+2+3+... = -1/12 and Co. " [VIDEO] * Vsauce: " The Banach–Tarski Paradox " [LINK] Each one is like half an hour long, but you may need to pause them and rewatch them a few times to understand the details. — gus_massa, 2022-04
It is weird, very weird. A very nice explanation of the proof is in a video by Mathologer " Ramanujan: Making sense of 1+2+3+... = -1/12 and Co. " [VIDEO] [spoiler alert] You can extend finite summations to infinite summations. The first extensions are nice and you get intuitive results, and are the extensions studied in Calculus in the university. But these extensions are not enough for this sum… — gus_massa, 2020-11
Related videos
- The Banach–Tarski Paradox · Vsauce · 24:13
- How to Understand What Black Holes Look Like · Veritasium · 9:18
- New Supercomputer Simulation Sheds Light on Moon’s Origin · NASA's Ames Research Center · 1:51
- Simulating an epidemic · 3Blue1Brown · 23:12
- Pounds, shillings, and pence: a history of English coinage · Lindybeige · 58:53
- High speed camera reveals why sodium explodes! · Thunderf00t · 24:59
- Building The World's First Computer - Greeks, Clocks and Rockets - Antikythera Mechanism Episode 1 · Clickspring · 6:52
- Numberphile v. Math: the truth about 1+2+3+...=-1/12 · Mathologer · 41:44
- Ruby Manor 3 - Programming with Nothing by Tom Stuart · Confreaks · 40:49
- Vectors | Chapter 1, Essence of linear algebra · 3Blue1Brown · 9:51
- But what is the Fourier Transform? A visual introduction. · 3Blue1Brown · 19:41
- But what is a neural network? | Deep learning chapter 1 · 3Blue1Brown · 18:40
- The Beauty of Bézier Curves · Freya Holmér · 24:25
- The Continuity of Splines · Freya Holmér · 1:13:50
- Jim Simons (full length interview) - Numberphile · Numberphile2 · 1:00:43
- Lec 1 | MIT 18.06 Linear Algebra, Spring 2005 · MIT OpenCourseWare · 39:49