The Machinery Of Freedom: Illustrated summary

Channel:bitbutter · Length:23:16 · Published:2012-04-04 · Views:163848

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An illustrated 23-minute summary of David Friedman's talk based on The Machinery of Freedom. It describes how law, police and courts could work as market services in a stateless society, covering private law, polycentric law and objections.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters use it as a short introduction to anarcho-capitalist ideas about private law and how disputes could be resolved without a state.

it's an illustrated talk by David D. Friedman, explaining how police, courts and other things would exist and work in a world without government — HN, 2014

Microeconomics & behavioral economics · Law, policing & justice · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

In the nineteenth century, the political philosophy that supported small government and free markets was called liberalism. Unfortunately between then and now the enemies of liberalism succeeded in stealing its name. Which is why people with similar views nowadays usually call themselves libertarians. The classical liberal, the nineteenth century liberal position, was that the function of government, was to do a few things that couldn't be done by individuals on the private market by voluntary association. And those were traditionally listed as police, courts and national defense. And I got interested, I suppose when I was oh in my late teens, in whether you could push the idea of free markets and voluntary association even farther than that. Whether it would be possible to have a society, which was organized by private property, trade, voluntary exchange, that set of ideas, but in which there was no government. In which all of the useful things government does, because government does some useful as well as some useless things, were done in other ways. And is attractive idea, because we have quite a lot of reasons to believe that where the same thing can be done either by government or privately, government usually do it worse.

On Hacker News

> Okay, let's say there's no governing body. Now, there's a dispute. How is it resolved? Fight to death? You've got an excellent question and I've got an excellent answer for you: [VIDEO] It's a short video, but I highly recommend it to you (skip the first minute or so for a short historical intro). Please come back here and let me know if it answered your question. I also hope it doesn't just an… — snitko, 2016-04
> There would be no courts for those who cannot afford to pay for them. That's one major difference. There would be no police, fire agencies, etc etc, I highy recommend you watch this video, it's an illustrated talk by David D. Friedman, explaining how police, courts and other things would exist and work in a world without government: [VIDEO] All of those things are just services. And the poor wo… — snitko, 2014-05
Funnily enough, as an anarchist, I never heard before that removing the government (or hierarchical use of violence) would remove violence from the world. There are plenty of ideas on how to keep law and order in an anarchic society. I recommend you to read The Machinery of Freedom (by David Friedman) or check out a summary here: [VIDEO] TLDR: One way to keep order is having private law enforceme… — jokethrowaway, 2020-09
I suggest you watch this short video then, which explains how laws, protection and private property can be created and enforced in a free market: [VIDEO] — snitko, 2014-08
As another reply has suggested, David Friedman's Machinery of Freedom is an excellent book which describes how private defense, law and dispute resolution might happen. This video is a good introduction to the ideas presented in the book [VIDEO] — pielud, 2014-02

Related videos