How Wrong Is VERITASIUM? A Lamp and Power Line Story

Channel:ElectroBOOM · Length:19:17 · Published:2021-12-08 · Views:4399417

Watch on YouTube

Summary

ElectroBOOM's Mehdi Sadaghdar responds to Veritasium's lamp-and-long-wire puzzle, analysing it as an electrical engineer. He covers where the original framing misleads and the role of stray capacitance.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as the more rigorous, polite and complete treatment of the Veritasium puzzle, though one dissents that the original misleads people.

Let me highly recommend Mehdi Sadaghdar’s (ElectroBOOM) excellent response video — HN, 2021

Electronics & circuit design · Fundamental physics

Subtitles (excerpt)

hi derek of veritasium made a video where he steps into my territory electronics and poses a question at the beginning and gives an answer at the end and his answer is wrong you should watch derek's video for full context of course his video is great and highly educational but his question wrapped me in ways that i didn't like it wasn't just a physics question it was a tricky question see if you want to raise your iq you get an book and a great deal from my link in the description thanks to my sponsor audible more at the end but a trick question is designed to trick not to test your knowledge something like a baby is hungry and will die now if not fed and the mother is nowhere to be seen what do we do i don't know we strap on a fetch breast and feed the baby no dummy open the closet door the mommy's in there the hell derek's question was imagine you have a giant circuit consisting of a battery a switch a light bulb and two wires which are each 300 000 kilometers long that is the distance light travels in one second well more like this now the question is when we flip the switch does it take half a second one second two seconds one over c seconds or none of the above for the lamp to turn on c is the speed of light and

On Hacker News

Controversial is fine to the extent the controversy shows people struggling toward clearer understanding and better explanations, and as long as all parties are operating in good faith (i.e. not being deliberately misleading). Let me highly recommend Mehdi Sadaghdar’s (ElectroBOOM) excellent response video [VIDEO] which does a great job of empirically investigating and theoretically explaining th… — jacobolus, 2021-12
In my opinion the video made a couple of mistakes, which I think ElectroBoom's response* addresses nicely. Also its proof using the pointing vector to show the flow of energy is misleading; In the video Derek shows that the energy flows toward the lamp when the circuit is already in a stable configuration, but the point of the video is to explore what happens before the circuit reaches that confi… — afiori, 2021-12
You should watch Electroboom's analysis if you want the full details from an electrical engineer: [VIDEO] — naasking, 2021-12
The veritasium video didn’t create a clear picture of what’s going on and you shouldn’t feel bad for feeling more confused after watching it ElectroBOOM has a good response [VIDEO] — haxiomic, 2021-12
Disclaimer: I don't understand nearly enough about the physics of electricity, but this was a popular response video by ElectroBOOM that Veritasium also responded to in the comments: [VIDEO] — aemreunal, 2022-01

Related videos