BBC - The Code - The Wisdom of the Crowd

Channel:timb6 · Length:4:48 · Published:2011-08-15 · Views:395385

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Marcus du Sautoy of the BBC demonstrates the wisdom of the crowd, showing that averaging many guesses of jelly beans in a jar lands near the true count.

Why HN recommends it

Used as a quick, convincing demonstration of crowd estimation when discussing aggregated judgment.

start at 2:00 if TLDW — HN, 2016

Probability & game theory · Recreational & visual math

Subtitles (excerpt)

3.1 as a crowd the patterns we make are incredibly predictable even as individuals our actions are controlled by the code Ro scissors and by untangling chaotic systems like the weather we've uncovered evidence of the code in what we once thought of as impossibly complex when we look at things from a different angle surprising patterns emerge patterns that can reveal defining truths about ourselves and our future in 1906 an unfortunate cow laid down its life for a place in mathematical history 1 10 264 417 the cow was the subject of a guess the weight competition at a Village Fair the lucky person who came closest would win the slaughtered animals meat 2020 2,13 the amazing thing was nobody guessed correctly 570 and yet everybody got it right 4,510 to show you how they did it I'm not going to use a cow I'm going to use a jar of jelly beans 450 800 12,000 7,000 how many jelly beans do you think there are in this jar um 50 uh 880,000 80,000 no actually 50,000 50,000 yeah okay 50 yeah okay it's incredibly difficult for anyone to guess how many Jelly Beans there are I asked 160 people and most were way off the Mark everything from 400 right up to 50,000 beans in fact only four people got

On Hacker News

This is brilliant and immediately reminded me of "wisdom of the crowd" [VIDEO] (start at 2:00 if TLDW). Basically average crowd > individuals. 160 people guess # of jelly beans in a jar. Few are close, but averaging all the guesses leads to 4 away from actual. Would be fascinating if applied to this as well... — botterworkshop, 2016-04
There are plenty of services that offer interview prep advice and numerous independent consulting services in feedback. These don't scale and not what I want to do. I'm doing more research and think there is something to "collective intelligence" or wisdom of the crowd. I'm not going to argue if a crowd is wise or not, but data show that the crowd gets it right within a fraction of the right answ… — applygo, 2015-09
While I agree with your critique about headline but "pessimistic" is wrong word as well. Question about wind and solar energy indicates that they are optimistic. People are simply wrong quite often. Here is "related" video about wisdom of crowd: [VIDEO] I wonder if we could apply idea of "wisdom of crowd" to those quiz questions. — daliusd, 2013-11

Related videos