The Energy Vault is a Dumb Idea, Here's Why

Channel:Adam Something · Length:3:50 · Published:2021-12-20 · Views:4742449

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Adam Something argues in four minutes that gravity batteries like Energy Vault, which lift concrete blocks with cranes, are a poor energy storage idea. He draws on a longer Thunderf00t debunk.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it as the go-to debunk when gravity storage projects appear, usually by commenters who think the idea is a dud.

This is a stupid idea, and there are some great YouTube videos that explain why[1]. — HN, 2022

Renewables, batteries & storage · Civil engineering & construction

Subtitles (excerpt)

so apparently the gravity battery is back in the spotlight I've seen news articles about it pop up recently and now it's time to stop the scrip before things get out of hand this will be short and sweet but if you want a more detailed take you can check out thunderers video link in the description H so what is the problem with this thing in energy production especially with Renewables we have periods of energy Surplus and energy deficit you need to put Surplus power somewhere so you can use it during a deficit but how do you store all that power do you build a giant battery yes and no this is where the gravity battery comes in in this case called Energy vol the concept itself sounds reasonable you have a bunch of cranes in the Middle with concrete blocks lying around when you have Surplus energy you use it to stack the blocks when you have an energy deficit you lower them down and spin a generator in the process here's their promotional video where the CEO talks about saving the world while stock music plays in the back how to solve one of the largest global problems facing our planet today how to store renewable energy in both an economical and sustainable way some a solution eliminated in the transportation sector so we

On Hacker News

> Or lifting a really heavy thing and letting it fall slowly. I challenge you to run the numbers on this. Or at least read or watch someone who has. Whenever you’re certain you know the answer, it behooves to try to prove yourself wrong. Unsurprisingly, gravity is an extraordinarily weak force. It merely appears otherwise because the total mass of the Earth is literally astronomical at around the… — perpetuallunch, 2026-08
My thoughts exactly. It makes the engineer in me go mad if I see projects like Energy Vault [1] getting massive funding that could be used to try and develop technologies that make sense. Thankfully there are some people who see through the charade [2]. If you are into this thing and looking for an even more stupid idea to store energy, I present to you the StEnSEA [3]. Rolls right off the tongue… — donquichotte, 2024-02
This is a stupid idea, and there are some great YouTube videos that explain why[1]. tl;dr We already move enormous amounts of drinking water, and reservoirs are much better (and cheaper) candidates for batteries than sand/cement/etc. 1. [VIDEO] — smt88, 2022-11
> But if you have an abundance of electrical power you can literally lift up concrete blocks with a crane and generate electricity by letting them down. That doesn't seem like the best idea if you think about it: [VIDEO] — armada651, 2022-08
Not worth it, easier to scale up battery manufacturing (which the world also needs for all vehicles to transition to electrification). [VIDEO] — toomuchtodo, 2022-07

Related videos