This giant model stopped a terrible plan

Channel:Tom Scott · Length:4:33 · Published:2016-12-01 · Views:9968976

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tom Scott tells how John Reber's plan to dam San Francisco Bay was disproved by the Army Corps of Engineers' giant hydraulic Bay Model in Sausalito. The model showed the plan would have been dangerously wrong.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a short, fascinating story of a scale model preventing a terrible engineering decision.

I learned of this plan via this short Tom Scott video. Fascinating. — HN, 2020

World history · Civil engineering & construction

Subtitles (excerpt)

These days if you want to simulate something in the physical world you use a computer. But what if you couldn't? What if it was, say, the 1950s and you needed to work out if a bold but questionable plan to dam the San Francisco Bay was a good idea? The answer is this: The US Army Corps of Engineers Bay Model. The Bay Model is one and a half acres or more. What you're looking at is one of our former scientific, hydrodynamic, engineering testing facilities. And this was the tool, the instrument, that they used to see what the unforeseen consequences of the John Reber Plan was going to be. In the 1940s and 50s a man named John Reber had a plan to completely change the San Francisco Bay. Enormous dams would create freshwater lakes. There'd be brand-new reclaimed land for industry and for air and naval bases. Reber said it would make the bay a defensible military fortification, move people safely inland and the newly dammed rivers would provide huge amounts of drinking water. Reber was not a professional engineer. He was a theatrical producer who had done a lot of research, but because he worked in showbiz, he knew how to promote something. And by most accounts he was a friendly, sincere, convincing man.

On Hacker News

If you don't know Tom Scott, he has done a great video 4mn vide on the model where you can see it in action: [VIDEO] — LucasLanglois, 2026-06
Yeaaaah, like that wouldn't have any unintended consequences. Meanwhile, I find this more interesting: [LINK] The Army Corps of Engineers literally built a scale model of the San Francisco Bay Area, and they used it to figure out that damming the SF Bay was a very, very bad idea: [VIDEO] — pmiller2, 2020-12
> It’s reminiscent of the plan suggested by a school teacher, to dam the San Francisco Bay, which was taken seriously enough to be modeled to scale by the military. For those unaware, I learned of this plan via this short Tom Scott video. Fascinating. [VIDEO] (4:33) — scrollaway, 2020-11
Tom Scott has a great video[0] about a similar attempt to dam the San Francisco Bay that got a lot closer to actually happening. So see if it was practical, the US Army Corps of Engineering built a giant scale model of the SF bay and put a dam on it to see what would happen. [0]: [VIDEO] — jedimastert, 2019-07
I don't think we can change the fact that people generally listen to what actors (and other charismatic people) have to say. This is nothing new. For a local example, San Francisco's John Reber, and the plan he pushed to turn the Bay into a freshwater lake ( [VIDEO] is a good video to watch). For a state (California) example, there's Arnold Schwarzenegger. For a national (US-level) example, there… — CaliforniaKarl, 2019-07

Related videos