Milton Friedman - Case Against Equal Pay for Equal Work

Channel:LibertyPen · Length:4:46 · Published:2010-01-04 · Views:867098

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip of Milton Friedman arguing with students that equal pay laws are counterproductive, and that markets penalize discrimination because cheaper equally productive workers are an advantage to hire.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in debates over pay equity law as Friedman's free-market argument on discrimination.

Milton explains it best — HN, 2017

Microeconomics & behavioral economics · Labor, work & inequality

Subtitles (excerpt)

equal pay for equal work laws are a Source of apartheid you know the basic source of apartheid in South Africa Was [the] insistence by trade unions on equal pay for equal work? The equal the women who go around today urging equal pay for equal work are being anti [feminists] they don't intend a bit, but that is the effect of their policy because if there is any [activity] in which for any reason a male is preferable to a female Or vice versa the only weapon the less productive sex has is to offer to work for less and if you deny them [that] opportunity You're assuring yourself that you're going to have all male jobs are all female jobs, or white jobs are all black job But aren't you also condemning them to stay that way not at all? Not at all the typical course if you go back to American history By taking these low paid jobs a great many people not all But a great many people were [able] to develop skills and activities accumulate a little skill a little capital a little knowledge improve their lot become Advanced in the stage Get to a higher level of productivity [and] get a higher income that's been the typical Way up the ladder for most of the people who came in here was a way up the ladder from my parents for your

On Hacker News

> When an employer chooses a white man over a black/brown/fuschia man even though the wage it's the same then it's not the law that is racist. It's the employer. Yes, but where there is no minimum wage, the racist employer has to pay a price for being racist because people of color are selling cheaper labor than white people, so if racist employer wants to hire white people only he will have to p… — patrickaljord, 2017-05
That's precisely the point Milton Friedman made regarding the 'wage gap' when asked about it 40 years ago. He noted that if one group of people could be every bit as productive as another at a fraction of the cost, that's a compelling competitive advantage. But as others became aware of the advantage, the overlooked group of people would find themselves more sought after. And that would drive up … — trentnix, 2020-12
That questioning of the gap being that big makes me think about this exchange Milton Friedman had with some college students in like the 70s or something regarding equal pay for equal work. [VIDEO] — jxramos, 2017-10
It's sad to see the tech community, which used to be very libertarian, move towards a hard-left progressive view of social issues. It wasn't that long ago that Friedman's arguments against equal pay laws[1] would have held sway here. The idea that the market punishes bigotry and so can be relied upon to advance freedom and equality used to be a core belief of the tech community. Now, it seems com… — redthrowaway, 2016-10

Related videos