JWST just made the "Crisis in Cosmology" WORSE

Channel:Dr. Becky · Length:16:36 · Published:2022-12-08 · Views:1295612

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Astrophysicist Dr. Becky explains the Hubble tension, the disagreement between expansion-rate measurements from the cosmic microwave background and the distance ladder, and what early JWST Cepheid observations add.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as an accessible layperson introduction to the Hubble tension when new expansion-rate results make the news.

she introduces laymen to the problems well — HN, 2024

Cosmology & astrophysics · Space exploration & spaceflight

Subtitles (excerpt)

in case you weren't aware there is a crisis in cosmology right now and I I use the term crisis very Loosely there essentially we have two main methods for working out the rate that the universe is expanding at and over the past couple of decades as instruments and techniques for doing that have gotten better and better those measurements have got more and more accurate but the estimates from those two methods have also diverged from each other to the point where they completely disagree now there's a two percent uncertainty on each measurement but a 10 difference between them now there's been a lot of effort in the past couple of years to try and resolve this crisis this tension between these two measurements a lot of which I've covered on this channel before so some of you might remember me saying this in a video back from July 2021 but then also the James Webb Space Telescope is going to help as well another thing on the James Webb's postal Scopes shoulders you know the crisis in cosmology is now resting care as well and a few weeks ago back in November 2022 we finally got a sneaky peek of what we've been waiting for with this paper paper by Yuan and collaborators describing some new observations from jwst of

On Hacker News

Dr.Becky goes over this in a video [0] from a year ago about the divergent results obtained by the two main ways we measure the rate of expansion. Cosmic Microwave Background Vs. Supernovae. As the accuracy of each method has improved, the end results have diverged. [0] 'theJWST just made the "Crisis in Cosmology" WORSE' [VIDEO] — harywilke, 2024-03
I can recommend Dr. Becky's introduction to the issues surrounding the Hubble Tension and recent JWST measurements in this 16 minute clip, as she introduces laymen to the problems well: [VIDEO] It's an older clip, but it checks out... ;) (still JWST discoveries and she most importantly introduces the viewer to the still remaining conflicts) — jug, 2024-03
Considering the two methods for measuring the rate of the universe’s expansion differ by about 10%, the question seems unsettled at best. You’re not wrong to question it. [VIDEO] — SkyMarshal, 2023-01
> "we can be absolutely confident of their fantastic distances" My current layperson's understanding is: 1) Redshift-to-distance conversion is a calibration based on the distance ladder. 2) And the distance ladder itself seems to have come under some doubt recently due to the "cosmological crisis" [1]. Can someone here ELI5 how they can be absolutely confident of these distances? [1] "JWST just m… — lovelearning, 2022-12

Related videos