RSA ANIMATE: First as Tragedy, Then as Farce

Channel:Royal Society of Arts · Length:10:57 · Published:2010-07-28 · Views:1886419

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An RSA Animate adaptation of a Slavoj Zizek talk on charitable giving and ethical consumerism. It argues that buying products that bundle a charity donation can sustain the system that causes the problems.

Why HN recommends it

Frequently linked in threads on philanthropy, ethical consumption and billionaire giving as a short, approachable critique of charity.

well worth a watch (10 minutes) and approachable by those without philosophical backgrounds — HN, 2015

Microeconomics & behavioral economics · Social issues & culture · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

I want to develop a very simple linear line of thought about one point why in our economy Clarity is no longer just an idiosyncrasy of some good guys here and there but the basic constituent of our economy I would like to start with a feature of so-called cultural capit capitalism today's form of capitalism and then develop how the same things thing applies also to economy in the narrower sense of the term namely if in the Old Times by old times I mean something very precise before this 68 transformation of capitalism into as we usually call it more cultural capitalism postmodern caring for Ecology and all that what changed what changed is that if before this time there was a simple more or less simple opposition between here it's consumation you buy you speculate and so on then on the top of it it comes what you do for a society like like Soros he's still the old type here I claim in the morning he grabs the money if I simplify it in the afternoon he gives half of the money back to Charities and supporting thing and so on but I claim in today's capitalism more and more the tendency is to bring the two Dimensions together in one of and the same gesture so that when you buy something your anti-consumer is duty to do something for others for environment

On Hacker News

This charity-as-part-of-consumerism is the topic of Zizek's talk First as Tragedy, Then as Farce ; well worth a watch (10 minutes) and approachable by those without philosophical backgrounds: [VIDEO] — mmanfrin, 2015-04
Slavoj Zizek discusses this idea of "ethical consumerism" in a beautifully illustrated talk here: [VIDEO] Needless to say, the idea that you are "supporting" something by voluntary exchange (how do you know that they aren't supporting you ?) is a relatively recent development, and is of course completely unworkable. It's just another form of retail therapy. — rsj_hn, 2022-12
>I know many people who buy into these 'good feelings' products. Good, quick talk by Zizek on this phenomenon: [VIDEO] — sithadmin, 2018-10
One interesting point is made by Slavoj Zizek on our society[0] about the "good" billionaires that give with one hand what they destroyed with the other. This what it feels like about all of what is happening over there, 1st world countries give "aid" to cover the problem themselves did over there. [0]: [VIDEO] — jeanlucas, 2019-08
I don't necessarily agree with you, but another interesting take on this is by Slavoj Zizek, who argues that charitable giving perpetuates the problem: [VIDEO] — iooi, 2018-09

Related videos