Freeman Dyson - Fermi's rejection of our work (94/157)

Channel:Web of Stories - Life Stories of Remarkable People · Length:6:35 · Published:2016-09-06 · Views:257366

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Freeman Dyson recounts how Enrico Fermi rejected his team's meson scattering model, noting that it had too many free parameters. It is the source of the quote about fitting an elephant.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in modeling and machine learning threads as the classic story on overfitting and justifying parameters.

you can watch Freeman Dyson recount this conversation in his own words in an interview — HN, 2024

Data science & statistics · Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication

On Hacker News

Freeman Dyson recounts the episode [1] that inspired this paper in his web of life interviews (prepositioned to the fitting an elephant bit) [2] [1] [VIDEO] [2] [VIDEO] — EdwardCoffin, 2024-07
> > In 1953, Enrico Fermi criticized Dyson’s model by quoting Johnny von Neumann: “With four parameters I can fit an elephant, and with five I can make him wiggle his trunk.” For those who are interested, you can watch Freeman Dyson recount this conversation in his own words in an interview: [VIDEO] — Calavar, 2024-07
I think a lot of people are really bad at evaluating world models. Feifei is right here that they are multimodal but really they must codify a physics. I don't mean "physics" but "a physics". I also think it's naïve to think this can be done through data alone. I mean just ask a physicist...[0]. But why people are really bad at evaluating them is because the details dominate. What matters here is… — godelski, 2025-11
> that does not have a technical meaning I don't think the definition is very refined, but I think we should be careful to differentiate that from useless or meaningless. I would say most definitions are accurate, but not precise. It's a hard problem, but we are making progress on it. We will probably get there, but it's going to end up being very nuanced and already it is important to recognize … — godelski, 2025-10
> only a small subset will contain actual understanding, a property that is independent of the model's input-output behavior? I think this is close enough. I'd say "a model's ability to make accurate predictions is not necessarily related to the model's ability to generate counterfactual predictions." I'm saying, you can make extremely accurate predictions with an incorrect world model. This isn'… — godelski, 2025-08

Related videos