Superintelligence: Science or Fiction? | Elon Musk & Other Great Minds

Channel:Future of Life Institute · Length:1:00:15 · Published:2017-01-31 · Views:663865

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A panel from the Beneficial AI 2017 conference moderated by Max Tegmark, with Elon Musk, Stuart Russell, Kurzweil, Hassabis, Harris, Bostrom, Chalmers and others. They discuss likely outcomes of human-level AGI and what outcomes are desirable.

Why HN recommends it

HN mostly cites it for specific statements, such as Hassabis on AGI and safety buffers, rather than recommending it outright.

AI safety, AGI & impact

Subtitles (excerpt)

I'm going to ask a question, but you can only answer by saying either 'yes,' 'no,' or 'it's complicated.' Alright? So, let's start over here. Is some form of superintelligence possible, Jaan? 'Yes,' 'no,' or 'it's complicated.' Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Definitely. No. Well, this was disappointing, we didn't find any disagreement. Let's try harder. Just because it's possible doesn't mean that it's actually going to happen. So, before I asked if superintelligence was possible at all according to the laws of physics. Now, i'm asking, will it actually happen? A little bit complicated, but yes. Yes, and if it doesn't then something terrible has happened to prevent it. Yes. Probably. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. No. Shucks, still haven't found any interesting disagreements. We need to try harder still. OK. So, you think it is going to happen, but would you actually like it to happen at some point? Yes, no, or it's complicated? Complicated, leaning towards yes. It's complicated. Yes. Yes. It's really complicated. Yes. It's complicated. Very complicated. Well, heck, I don't know. It depends on which kind. Alright, so it's getting a little bit more interesting. When I think, we had a really fascinating...

On Hacker News

"And what would excite me about actually the birth of superintelligent AI - one of the things, apart from solving obvious problems like curing disease and energy issues and all the rest, perhaps differs a little bit with what Stuart said. I’m not so worried about idiocracy or all of us just losing our way as apes and living unproductive lives in dialogue with these oracles. I think actually, I wo… — passion__desire, 2022-12
Demis Hassabis. [VIDEO] , older [LINK] (NB ‘likely’ ≠ ‘>50%’, not sure what his percentage would be) I can give more but I did upstream link to a paper on this so it seems pretty pointless. — Veedrac, 2021-03
Top people including DeepMind's CEO Demis Hassabis and Prof Stuart Russell, a AAAI and AAAS fellow who is a co-author of the AI textbook used at most of top universities, agree that AGI is definitely possible and going to happen. [1] Hassabis also stated in another session that there are probably at least half a dozen mountains to climb before reaching AGI and he would be surprised if it takes mo… — nopinsight, 2017-07
DeepMind's mission is to build AGI. I think it's probably good if they have a buffered lead on all other efforts. That concern probably weighs on decisions about releasing code. The rationale for why a buffer would be good is described by Demis Hassabis here: [VIDEO] ...the main points are: there may be safety considerations along the way that are costly. More "capitalistic" organizations may dec… — rojobuffalo, 2017-05
> This is silly and ridiculously judgmental No it really is not. Just watching this panel/Q&A at the 'Future of Life Institute', with Elon Musk and others answering the question "is some form of super-intelligence possible?", creeps me out (Musk comes out the most sane): [VIDEO] > The author’s point is that by (say) 2050 we will likely see AI asking unsettlingly “intelligent” questions More unset… — beckman466, 2021-03

Related videos