Václav Smil at Driva Climate Investment Meeting 2019
Channel:Nysnø Klimainvesteringer · Length:52:10 · Published:2019-06-17 · Views:38285
Summary
Vaclav Smil's talk on historic energy transitions and what they imply for climate investment. He argues that transitions are slow, technology improves gradually, and only absolute cuts in energy use would truly work.
Why HN recommends it
Frequently linked as a sobering, data-grounded counterpoint to techno-optimism about decarbonization and green growth.
Here's a fascinating talk by Václav Smil at the Driva Climate Investment Meeting in 2019 — HN, 2021
Climate science & climate change · Climate policy, solutions & debate · Renewables, batteries & storage
Subtitles (excerpt)
and welcome to part one energy is the only universal currency the title of this part is taken from one of the many books that our next speaker Bosh loves meal has written Bosh love has researched a wide range of subjects over his 40 years as a scientists he musters energy in all its forms from the broad energy transitions to the minut detail gosh laughs we are looking forward to hearing your views on our energy perspective to be here I was asked to give a big picture about energy transitions which is something I always keen to do because too few people appreciate how difficult it will be how expensive it will be and how long it will take my experience over past decade or so is that it's especially difficult in Europe because European things are somehow externality Greenwich they are naturally for iying to Thailand over the weekend is not very green really flying for 29 euro from others you never think if you need to go do anything on you know from Helsinki to Cyprus that's not very green because flying is the most energy intensive way of human transportation but for some reason European things are greener than anybody else they aren't but more important than you think that we can somehow do this if not by next Monday by 2030 no miss
On Hacker News
> the degrowth position is that people are inevitably going to lead worse lives than at present, but that we can choose between things getting kind of bad, by systematically pursuing degrowth, and things getting apocalyptically bad, which is what will happen if we continue pursuing growth I can't speak for others who advocate for degrowth, but that seems about right to me, with the caveat that I … — carapace, 2024-09
> the ability to dramatically reduce world hunger is a direct consequence of humans' capacity to improve crop yields such as rice and corn through breeding and engineering. Not through "breeding and engineering", through artificial nitrogen fertilizer. We have been turning oil into people . > prevented the starvation of millions of people. That delayed the starvation of millions of people and now… — carapace, 2022-03
Here's a fascinating talk by Václav Smil at the Driva Climate Investment Meeting in 2019: [VIDEO] Bill Gates calls him "one of my favorite thinkers" and reviews his recent book "Growth": > Vaclav Smil ... reaches the ... conclusion: Earth is fragile and “before it is too late, we should embark in earnest on the most fundamental existential [task] of making any future growth compatible with the lo… — carapace, 2021-10
On the other hand 1/2 of world looks more or less the same - rural Africa, india, china... If you believe we are highly adaptable and new technologies will 'save us' somehow check this presentation : [VIDEO] ...it's eye opening — raaaaraaaa2, 2019-08
I recall Vaclav Smil saying batteries are consistently about 2-3% per year over the long haul. It's not a Moore's law scenario, but a very slow crawl. "Miracles might happen," he says, "but would I bet on a miracle happening? No." This link is to the point in the video where he says this, but the whole talk is quite interesting. [VIDEO] Edit: here's a more recent video of Smil talking about energ… — aksss, 2021-12
Related videos
- Treating the Farm as an Ecosystem with Gabe Brown Part 1, The 5 Tenets of Soil Health · Living Web Farms · 2:31:00
- Should Google Go Nuclear? Clean, cheap, nuclear power (no, really) · GoogleTalksArchive · 1:32:38
- Exponential growth and epidemics · 3Blue1Brown · 8:56
- The Future of Mathematics? · Microsoft Research · 1:14:48
- That scene from War Games · Greg Granito · 4:05
- NYC Tech Talk Series: How Google Backs Up the Internet · Google TechTalks · 1:14:18
- [4k, 60 fps] San Francisco, a Trip down Market Street, April 14, 1906 · Denis Shiryaev · 14:22
- Gwynne Dyer -- Geopolitics in a Hotter World · The University of British Columbia · 1:31:52
- The Real Reason Jaywalking Is A Crime (Adam Ruins Everything) · Dropout · 3:24
- Stanford Seminar - Concatenative Programming: From Ivory to Metal · Stanford Online · 1:04:44
- William Byrd on "The Most Beautiful Program Ever Written" [PWL NYC] · PapersWeLove · 1:31:05
- Michael Levin: Anatomical decision-making by cellular collectives · Thomas Ouldridge · 1:18:06
- India's Water Revolution #1: Solving the Crisis in 45 days with the Paani Foundation · Andrew Millison · 9:02
- Domain Modeling Made Functional - Scott Wlaschin · NDC Conferences · 51:39
- Energy Investments Dialogue | Bill Gates | Global Energy Forum · Stanford ENERGY · 36:12
- Drip Coffee Makers — super simple, super cheap · Technology Connections · 36:28