Richard Feynman: "What's the name of a bird?"

Channel:Yves Messer · Length:1:39 · Published:2013-09-27 · Views:48416

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip from a 1973 NOVA episode in which Richard Feynman recalls his father teaching him that knowing the name of a bird in many languages tells you nothing about the bird.

Why HN recommends it

Reached for whenever a thread touches on naming versus actually understanding something.

You can know the name of a bird in many different languages, but that tells you nothing about it. — HN, 2023

Education & learning · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

feineman is in the Forefront of one of the oldest and most intriguing games of hideand-seek in science finding the ultimate constituent of the world in this search Fineman is a celebrated Maverick who was encouraged by his father a New York Clothing salesman to confront conventional wisdom one Sunday all the kids were all walking in little parties with their fathers in the woods then the next Monday we were playing in a field and the kid said to me say what's that bird what's the name of do you know the name of that bird I says I have the slightest idea he said well it's a brown throated thrush he says your father doesn't teach you anything but my father had already taught me about the names of birds he once we walked and he says that's a brth of thrush he says no what the name of that bird it's a brown thr in German it's called a in Chinese it's called aong Japanese and so on and when you know all the names in every language of that bird you know nothing but absolutely nothing about the bird then we would go on and talk about the pecking in the feathers so I had learned already that names don't constitute knowledge if knowing the name of something that's caused me a certain trouble since because I refuse to learn the name of anything so when someone comes

On Hacker News

If you dont mind listening to Richard himself, you can watch this pre-historic 4:3 videos on youtube; [VIDEO] [LINK] — Quai, 2020-08
Richard Feynman: [VIDEO] The names of birds. tl;dw: Knowing the name of something gives you no knowledge of that thing even if you can name it in every language but it's super useful to know when communicating with others. — s_dev, 2026-01
It's not that simple. LLMs are great for predicting next word, but this needs a more unsupervised approach. Ultimately, you need to know the environment of whales. Sure, you know the next probable token, and even relationships between tokens, but how do they relate to what whales are doing? , in other words what does it mean? . It reminds me of the great quote by Feynman: "look at the bird"[1]. Y… — gnramires, 2023-12
Though he does admit [1] > So I had learned already that names don't constitute knowledge... That's caused me a certain trouble since because I refuse to learn the name of anything... What [my father] forgot to tell me was that the knowing the names of things is useful if you wanna talk to somebody else. I think an interview might count :) [1] [VIDEO] — scythmic_waves, 2021-11
I suspect the joy for people versed in classic theory is sparked from being able to identify the name of a recurring concept in a segment of a classical music piece. On a related note: [VIDEO] — incrudible, 2021-09

Related videos