Your Product Sucks — Apple Music macOS review

Channel:Your Product Sucks · Length:17:56 · Published:2020-10-30 · Views:39044

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A profane video review in the Your Product Sucks series that picks apart the Apple Music app on macOS Catalina and its usability problems.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it, with schadenfreude, as evidence that Apple Music on desktop is poorly built.

UX & UI design · Satire & parody

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] i didn't want to do this but someone on the reddit said music app on mac os catalina is not so great not so great that sounds like it's okay like it's acceptable it's not not so great it's [ __ ] awful it's an abomination there could be no god if that thing exists now i'm only talking about mac os not the ios version ios version is fine it has problems but whatever nobody gives a [ __ ] about desktop nowadays right apple doesn't give a [ __ ] about desktop and people say well itunes itunes was so bad itunes was fine it wasn't a problem with itunes apple music was always this [ __ ] weird webview within itunes and it was at least it was working it's i'm biased as you can hear i actually like apple music i i want to love it i i really do because i i like it in principle more than spotify because spotify is like facebook it just pushes random playlists into your face and podcasts all that stuff apple music at least feels like they care about music it feels like a record store where you browse music and stuff when it works i've been a subscriber to apple music for a long time and then i quit just for you now i'm gonna re-subscribe just to show you how bad it is so right this video cost me 10 bucks when i run this apple music thing

On Hacker News

Apple Music has been utterly awful on desktop for years, with virtually zero positive progress. I made this angry video [1] 4 years ago, and have tried using Apple Music multiple times since then, and it never failed to disappoint. 1. [VIDEO] — freetonik, 2024-11
Like it's broken beyond all recognition and hope with all interactions and expectations of a native app just gone. See this review: [VIDEO] — dmitriid, 2021-09
"unique style of content" is a strange way to describe a lackluster library. It doesn't even seem to be improving. There is not a lot of new content compared to 6 month ago (when I first checked). Unless you're very into one of few shows, it's not worth it. And it's not me speaking. They offer 1 year free trial! Who does this? I have't tried other services, so I cannot comment. Although, Apple Mu… — fluxem, 2021-07
In the past few years Apple has dropped the ball on HIG and MacOS. Here's AppStore mini-review: [LINK] "Get 15 people, put them in 15 different offices with no communication between them, set them to work on one feature at a time. You will get something very similar to the App Store." Here's Apple Music review (spoiler: swearing): [VIDEO] — dmitriid, 2021-05
Assuming you mean Apple Music (iTunes was an okay MP3 player/ripper, but is dead), I consider it the exception that proves the rule. Enjoy the schadenfreude of this recent Apple Music for macOS review: [VIDEO] — CharlesW, 2021-04

Related videos