NSA operation ORCHESTRA: Annual Status Report

Channel:HUP · Length:46:06 · Published:2014-02-12 · Views:29995

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Poul-Henning Kamp's FOSDEM 2014 talk is a hypothetical account of how an intelligence agency such as the NSA would sabotage open source software, standards and online discussion. It covers Skype's history, OpenSSL and psyops against standards.

Why HN recommends it

HN returned to it repeatedly, especially after Heartbleed, as an eye-opening argument about subverting open source and standards.

The entire talk is an eye opener. — HN, 2014

Linux & open-source ecosystems · Security & hacking · Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime

Subtitles (excerpt)

thank you all for joining us uh we are going to have uh po Henning Camp also or maybe better known as phk um on annual status report on NSA operation Orchestra welcome thank you so a couple of years ago there was a news item that made me sit up in the chair and think um it's probably not the one you think about now the director of CIA had his love affair exposed by the FBI because they traced his telecommunication uh being a security researcher which is not normally something I call myself uh is a matter of imagination in a situation like that you need to sit back and try to think like the minds who did that um later on we got Edwards noon's disclosures and I sat down and I thought what would I do if I have at budget a$1 billion and a mandate an order to collect as much communication as possible um then a week ago I got an email from Phillip going like H I need a keynote speaker what are you doing next weekend and since I owe Philip a lot of favors I said I can do that and um then I sat down and made a set of slides um the basic premise here is that you should imagine a junior NSA staffer arriving in Brussels to give a update to Nato on one of the NSA programs and then because he's American he ends up here

On Hacker News

Check out phk's fosdem talk[0]. I've linked to the the part where he talks about openSSL, but I'd suggest watching the whole thing. I'm now starting to believe the talk wasn't a joke at all... [0] [VIDEO] — ensmotko, 2014-04
There's a talk that was given in Belgium / Brussels at FOSDEM2014 two months ago or so by Poul-Henning Kamp (FreeBSD) regarding the NSA and how he'd do it if he had to create holes in software: [VIDEO] He's talking specifically about OpenSSL quite a lot (basically saying it's too complex to ever be secure and probably received many "security patches" from NSA employees). The entire talk is an eye… — TacticalCoder, 2014-04
I think open-source software is great as well, but assuming these kind of bugs are found because you can inspect the code is very wishful thinking that doesn't always hold up. This specific example required a Google department to find it. Who would have found it if Google got restrained by the NSA?. Other notable examples include openSSL. On top of that, here is a great talk about how easy it wou… — askmike, 2019-10
>I have this notion that surrounding a subject with basket case conspiracy theories would be a good way to get people not to take it seriously :) Indeed, it would. A lot of clever people have discussed the issue of disinfo & FUD, you might wish to: * Watch this talk from FOSDEM '14 by Poul-Henning Kamp [Contextually, one important tidbit to keep in mind while watching it: At the time phk gave the… — no_identd, 2018-09
This talk was an interesting thought experiment by PhK of FreeBSD on how if he were tasked by some agency to sabotage open source projects and standards how he would go about doing it [VIDEO] A talk by Robert Harper at OPLSS in 2017 is really good as well, covering the basics of programming language background [LINK] "concrete syntax is where computer science meets psychology.... at the moment it… — hackermailman, 2018-04

Related videos