David Deutsch: A new way to explain explanation

Channel:TED · Length:17:15 · Published:2009-10-26 · Views:246631

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Physicist David Deutsch's TED talk on why science took off, arguing that good explanations are those that are hard to vary. It contrasts scientific explanation with myth.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to it as a short, tight introduction to Deutsch's idea of hard-to-vary explanations.

it's a very tight talk and you should start from the beginning — HN, 2023

Philosophy & ethics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

I'm sure that, throughout the 100,000-odd years of our species' existence and even before, our ancestors looked up at the night sky and wondered what stars are -- wondering, therefore, how to explain what they saw in terms of things unseen. OK, so, most people only wondered that occasionally, like today, in breaks from whatever normally preoccupied them. But what normally preoccupied them also involved yearning to know. They wished they knew how to prevent their food supply from sometimes failing, and how they could rest when they were tired without risking starvation, be warmer, cooler, safer, in less pain. I bet those prehistoric cave artists would have loved to know how to draw better. (Laughter) In every aspect of their lives, they wished for progress, just as we do. But they failed, almost completely, to make any. They didn't know how to. Discoveries like fire happened so rarely that, from an individual's point of view, the world never improved. Nothing new was learned. The first clue to the origin of starlight happened as recently as 1899: radioactivity. And within 40 years, physicists discovered the whole explanation, expressed, as usual, in elegant symbols. But never mind the symbols.

On Hacker News

As kevinwang has pointed out in slightly different terms: the hypothesis that seems wooly to you seems sharply pointed to others (and vice versa) because explanationless hypotheses ("changing the colour of the button will help") are easily variable (as are the colour of the xkcd jelly beans), while hypotheses that are tied strongly to an explanation are not. You can test an explanationless hypoth… — thingification, 2023-06
Great essay, deeper than being about just Bayesianism. In the essay David talks a lot about explanations and what is good one v/s a bad one. The short TED lecture by him gives a deeper insight into his explanation of why good explanations (hard to vary theory of the world) are the key to scientific and human progress since the scientific revolution. (17 min at 1x) [VIDEO] — npalli, 2022-04
You have to be careful with the "Explanation(Understanding) vs. Prediction" dichotomy. They are related but Explanations should always have precedence since they are fundamental to creating a Theory in the first place that then can make Predictions. David Deutsch actually argues for Understanding/Explanations over Predictions. Here is a nice Reddit thread on this; David Deutsch argues that explan… — rramadass, 2026-07

Related videos