Joe Armstrong & Alan Kay - Joe Armstrong interviews Alan Kay

Channel:Erlang Solutions · Length:1:16:55 · Published:2016-11-22 · Views:76497

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Joe Armstrong, creator of Erlang, interviews Alan Kay at Code Mesh. They discuss the meaning of object orientation, message passing, the META II paper, and the state of computer science.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it in debates about what OOP originally meant, since Kay's message-passing view lines up with Erlang's processes.

To get some perspective on both of their perspectives, here's "Joe Armstrong interviews Alan Kay" — HN, 2021

Functional programming · Software architecture & design · Tech pioneers & interviews

Subtitles (excerpt)

I actually went in and asked Joe and Alan how they would like to be introduced and Alan was very quick in saying, "Oh, we're two old guys who've been around for a while." And to which Joe you're very helpful interjects, "Yes, we're the ones who helped create the mess we're in." Of course, he's he's much younger. And this is where you know a a quote from oh sir Tony Hoare who was on this very stage this time last year came up and it was that Algol was a great improvement on its successor. And you know, I think it's people who've helped us get to where we are today who will have a very good insight into where into telling us where we actually are today and not where we who use this technology believe we are. And in a way you know, this is a theme of what this conference is all about and this is the perfect way you know, to wrap up. So, I'll leave it over to Alan who will give us an insight. hello Joe. How are you? It's a movie. That was such a hit maybe we should quit now. Okay. So, Joe asked me to uh spend 15 minutes and I will try and maybe somebody can help me. Um to uh he wanted to he wanted me to spend 15 minutes to say where we were all wrong, but um that is a much longer talk. So, what I thought I would do is to go back into the past and show a couple of

On Hacker News

Thanks, I'll check it out! When I implemented messaging for Abject, I used the Erlang model. I also added P2P support so objects can talk across the network. There is this great discussion between Joe Armstrong and Alan Kay if you haven't see it. [VIDEO] EDIT: Just checked your smalltalk implementation. Very cool! Do you remember the Open Croquet project in the early 2000s? Way ahead of it's time… — mempko, 2026-07
Indeed, here's a email from Alan Kay about how his perspective is about "messaging" between objects: [LINK] (edit: derp, this is directly cited in TFA) Also, I loved this interview/discussion between Kay & Joe Armstrong, inventor of Erlang, where the topic comes up again (because Erlang is also a lot about messaging between agents) [VIDEO] — AceJohnny2, 2025-05
One sort-of exception is Erlang (and anything else that runs on the BEAM vm, like Elixir). It doesn't match Alan Kay's vision exactly, because the message passing is done a bit differently (for example it's asynchronous), but creator Joe Armstrong called it something like "the best of functional programming and OOP". If you come from C++, Java, or other "OOP" languages, and look at Erlang, it's c… — Rendello, 2021-11
Checking out what Alan Kay has to say about it might help: [VIDEO] The way i see it OOP is about encapsulating/bundling data and the code that processes that data into one "object", that is isolated from other objects. The objects could only "communicate" with other objects by sending "messages" (data/events/something). Personally i don't like OOP, and think that focusing on data and how it's pro… — gens, 2020-05
Concurrency.. the way i understand it, it is about making parts of the program run independent of each other and thus can run at the same time. But you might want to check out someone who knows better, like Rob Pike: [LINK] Yes, Erlang makes concurrent programs easier to write. Again it is better to listen to someone who knows more, like the creator of Erlang Joe Armstrong: [LINK] Any talk by him… — gens, 2020-04

Related videos