Keynote: Greg Kroah-Hartman (Linux Foundation) - "I Don't Want Your Code"

Channel:Linaro On Air · Length:33:36 · Published:2013-03-07

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Greg Kroah-Hartman's Linaro keynote on contributing to the Linux kernel, explaining why maintainers prefer upstreamed code and how they view contributions.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in discussions of maintainer burden and why companies benefit from upstreaming drivers, as an explanation straight from a lead kernel maintainer.

Greg Kroah-Hartman explains it — HN, 2023

Software practice, open source & careers · Linux & open-source ecosystems

Subtitles (excerpt)

maintainer I maintain the stable Linux kernels uh lenus does the development kernels every three months I do a stable kernel about every week um I also do the driver core USB debug FS TTY and serial I've been doing serial for like 25 years my first paid job and I'm still doing it um and I do a lot of colel stuff um I'm a maintainer also um so at the end of my goal at the end of this talk is to for you to understand why we are as obnoxious as we are and why you would never want to do this job okay but first some numbers these are always fun this is the Linux kernel for last year uh 3.4 to 3.8 years worth of development um 3,000 individual developers at least 400 I'm guessing about 420 companies I haven't done all the numbers um this is the largest software development process in the history of us um this huge it's really really really big um it's just amazingly big let quote Douglas Adams um and it's going really really fast um I run the numbers every release and they keep scaring me um but last year think about this almost seven changes an hour 24 hours a day seven days a week uh the year before that we were at 5.9 year before that 5.0 we keep going faster and that's really really important for you to know we're going faster and so what you

On Hacker News

Because it leads to straight up better products and companies that don't upstream the drivers get outcompeted by the ones that do. Greg Kroah-Hartman explains it: [VIDEO] — matheusmoreira, 2023-12
[VIDEO] for a video version of this talk One funny bit about the talk, which isn’t mentioned in the slides, is that he actually gave the talk at Linaro (the very same company who were called out in the slides as a case study of submitting a particularly bad set of patches) — jamespwilliams, 2023-09
Because then consumers get hardware that works out of the box on Linux. That's how good corporations contribute. [VIDEO] — matheusmoreira, 2023-03
> it's not the publishing but the use which is proscribed - same applies for engineering Exactly. I think there should be an exception for free and open source software though. We have lots of free software designed to be used by people. I don't think these programmers should be held liable. Many of them are amateurs and volunteers. The chilling effect would simply be too great. I'm reminded of G… — matheusmoreira, 2021-10
> maybe it's time to have sub-maintainers to whom such tasks could be delegated They already have subsystem maintainers. The result was an even faster process. [VIDEO] — matheusmoreira, 2021-06

Related videos