Why build an entire computer on breadboards?

Channel:Ben Eater · Length:28:43 · Published:2020-04-04 · Views:3381159

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Ben Eater explains why he builds computers on breadboards, including testing their signal behavior on an oscilloscope. It is a companion to his 6502 breadboard computer series.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as the answer to why breadboard computers are worth building and why breadboards work at these speeds.

Ben Eater had a whole video on why he encourages building a breadboard computer. — HN, 2021

Computer architecture & CPUs · Electronics & circuit design · Embedded systems & DIY electronics

Subtitles (excerpt)

is it a good idea to build an entire computer from scratch on bread boards like this well it might seem like a strange question for someone who's basically made an entire youtube channel out of doing precisely that and I sell kits with all the parts so you can do it yourself so obviously I'm a pretty big fan of building computers on bread boards and the big reason I really like it is that it forces you to think through how everything works you know what I felt like something was missing with these projects where you get a premade circuit board and you just solder a bunch of components to it and don't get me wrong it's great if you want to learn how to solder but once you know that I I just don't see how attaching a bunch of components to a circuit board teaches you much about electronics in fact the typical experience is that you solder the whole thing together plug it in and it it just works the first time there's nothing to troubleshoot there's no need to understand how it works and so you don't this on the other hand you know it really forces you to think about each individual connection to each pin and as you build each section testing it you know each as you go there's a very good chance things

On Hacker News

Ben Eater had a whole video on why he encourages building a breadboard computer. [VIDEO] A lot of people have taken what they've learned and moved on to designing their own PCB versions. You can see some of them here: [LINK] — eco, 2021-12
I got caught up in all his videos and had the same question. Fortunately, he has a dedicated video where he answers this with testing on the scope: [VIDEO] tl;dr is what the sibling comment already explained: low clock rates. — 205guy, 2020-11
I think this is good advice. It reminds me of the advice about that the difference between a hoard and a collection is the display case. It's great to have the interests and you like what you like, but if it's just a never ending pile that is damaging other pursuits it's no good for you, but if it's something you can catalog, explore, curate, and especially share in a meaningful way then having t… — stuntkite, 2022-04

Related videos