Flat Earth "Science" -- Wrong, but not Stupid

Channel:Sabine Hossenfelder · Length:15:50 · Published:2020-08-22 · Views:2067602

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Sabine Hossenfelder explains what flat earthers believe and why, arguing that their reasoning is wrong but not stupid. She suggests scientists should take such believers more seriously.

Why HN recommends it

Pointed to in discussions about engaging with fringe beliefs and distrust of institutions rather than dismissing people.

I would point interested folks to an interesting video by Sabine Hossenfelder — HN, 2022

Religion, belief & skepticism · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

I, as many people in science communication, am fascinated with flat earthers. Here you have a group of people steadfastly rejecting evidence that’s right in their face. Today, I want to tell you why I nevertheless think flat earthers are neither stupid nor anti-scientific. Most of them, anyway. More importantly, I also want to explain why you should not be embarrassed if you can’t remember how we know that the earth is round. But first I have to tell you what flat earthers actually believe and how they got there. The most popular flat earth model is that of a disk where the North pole is in the middle and the south pole is an ice wall on the edge of the disk. But not all flat earthers sign up to this. An alternative is the so-called bipolar model where both poles are on the disk, surrounded by water that’s held by a rim of something, maybe ice or rocks. And a minority of flat earthers believe that earth is really an infinite plane. They mostly agree though that gravity does not exist, and that the observations we normally attribute to gravity come instead from the upward acceleration of the flat earth. As a consequence, the apparent gravitational acceleration is the same everywhere on earth.

On Hacker News

To those who say that flat earthers don’t exist in reality… There’s a guy who drives around town where my parents live in Arizona with his flat earth position writ large on the side of his pickup truck. He will stop to debate with you even if you’re next to him at a traffic light. [1] I think flat earthers do exist but the majority of them may not admit it openly if they’re still sufficiently “th… — Method5440, 2022-01
You may never convince someone to be rational but you may convince the interlocutors. Otherwise you're creating martyrs. Everyone has a valid point, even flat earthers. [VIDEO] — hotdogscout, 2023-08
Soon every piece of information will have cryptographic claim(s) attached. Everything that can attach it will have cryptographic identity. Everything will likely evolve into some (weighted/probabilistic?) crypto-tree of trust. There won't be absolute truth, only truth scores according to some defined trust sets/trees. Imagine fake news, pictures, videos, voice generated at scale, indistinguishabl… — mirekrusin, 2022-12

Related videos