The Truth about Hydrogen

Channel:Real Engineering · Length:14:58 · Published:2018-07-27 · Views:5668772

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Real Engineering examines the efficiency of hydrogen as an energy carrier. It follows production, storage and fuel cell conversion losses and compares hydrogen cars with battery electric vehicles.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it in hydrogen threads as a clear breakdown of why compounded inefficiencies make hydrogen a poor fit for cars, though one commenter calls it outdated.

This video gives a good breakdown on how the inefficiencies in hydrogen fuel cell based cars add up. — HN, 2021

Renewables, batteries & storage · Cars, EVs & motorcycles

Subtitles (excerpt)

This episode of Real Engineering is brought to you by Skillshare, home to over twenty thousand classes that could teach you a new life skill. As the world grapples to eliminate fossil fuels from our energy diet, electric cars have seen an incredible boom over the past few years. Last year, over one million electric cars were sold around the world. The number of Nissan Leafs, Teslas, and other electric vehicles in circulation worldwide is now more than three million. And while there are many brands of electric car to choose from, there are only two choices when it comes to powering electric vehicles: fuel cells or batteries. Both produce electricity to drive electric motors, eliminating the pollution and inefficiencies of the fossil fuel powered internal combustion engine. Both hydrogen and electricity for batteries can be produced from low­ or zero ­carbon sources, including renewable energy like solar and wind, and therefore both are being pursued by car manufacturers and researchers as the possible future of electric vehicles. However, a great debate is being waged by supporters of each technology. Elon Musk has called hydrogen fuel cell technology “incredibly dumb,” claiming they’re

On Hacker News

[VIDEO] This video gives a good breakdown on how the inefficiencies in hydrogen fuel cell based cars add up. The best case scenario for hydrogen based land transport I can think of is probably in the trucking industry where engine weight, range and refuelling time are important factors — rdedev, 2021-03
Hydrogen is not a good (at the moment at least) source of energy or fuel for cars or industry (chemically speaking, obviously much better together with Deuterium and Tritium for fission, though we are still from such a technology). Steam reforming, which is currently the most common way of hydrogen production, uses natural gas and water and produces plenty of CO2 [1]. Nice summary as for cars fue… — nuccy, 2020-09
Now I'm curious how Hyundai or the stations actually produce the hydrogen fuel. Edit: this video had a good overview of the various production methods, including on-site at the fuel station [VIDEO] — dmix, 2020-07
I am sorry you are so misinformed. Lithium is a common abundant resource and battery packs are easily recycled but more importantly there is a financial incentive to do so. Manufacturing technology for cells is improving rapidly. Much faster than the pace of innovation in Hydrogen fuel cells. Most are focusing on reducing Cobalt and other techniques to reduce or eliminate chemicals and energy use… — mcot2, 2020-01
Storing energy as hydrogen is much less efficient than storing energy in batteries. The channel Real Engineering explains: [VIDEO] ; [LINK] — nayuki, 2018-12

Related videos