Dr Shashi Tharoor MP - Britain Does Owe Reparations

Channel:OxfordUnion · Length:15:29 · Published:2015-07-14 · Views:12145341

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Shashi Tharoor's Oxford Union speech arguing that Britain owes reparations to its former colonies, focused on the effects of British rule in India. It lists economic and political damage done by colonialism.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters link it repeatedly in colonial history threads as an eloquent, fact-dense short speech.

This talk has many facts not even commonly known to Indians. — HN, 2019

Geopolitics & foreign policy · World history

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] [Music] president and gentlemen ladies of the house I standing here with 8 minutes uh in my hands and uh at this venerable and rather magnificent institution I was going to assure you that I belong to the Henry VII School of Public Speaking that as Henry VII said to his wives I shall not keep you long but now finding myself but now finding myself the seventh speaker out of eight in what must already seem a rather long evening to you I rather feel like Henry the H's last wife I more or less know what's expected of me but I'm not sure how to do it any differently perhaps what I should do is ready try and pay attention to the arguments that were Advanced by the opposition today we had for example Sir Richard OT suggesting they challenging the very idea that it could be argued that the economic situation of the colonies was actually worsened by the experience of British colonialism well I stand to offer you the Indian example Sir Richard India's share of the world economy when Britain arrived on its Shores was 23% by the time the British left it was down to below 4% why simply because India had been governed for the benefit of Britain in Britain's rise for 200 years was financed

On Hacker News

Yeah, but we are talking about India under british empire. Not Rwanda and Haiti. Since you're so oblivious of what the british empire did, here's a 8 minute mini speech of things British empire did in India. India wasn't some poor country, it was actually one of the richest countries in the world before brits came along and stole everything. This was my entire point in the initial post, it's both… — parthdesai, 2023-01
The video linked by parent is light on details. This one has more details if anyone's interested (A debate on the empire but many of the things apply to EIC) [VIDEO] — hawk_, 2022-10
Mr. Tharoor is a current Member of Parliament of India and previously India's Ambassador to the UN. He is a very eloquent speaker and writer. Here's his famous short speech at the Oxford Union where he made a case for reparations from Britain for its excesses during its reign of the Indian subcontinent. [VIDEO] — vivegi, 2022-09
This argument is somewhat disingenuous with cherry-picked examples which are highly dependent on Time and Context. Colonialism ruined whole countries leaving them poor, rewrote cultural narratives, uprooted entire social structures and in a word, destroyed peoples histories and a sense of their own independent identity. In the bloody aftermath some flourished and some did not; but this cannot be … — rramadass, 2021-11
Regarding 'helped unify India as a nation', they are not the first. Referring to [LINK] , India's map looked close to the present day multiple times in the past. Maurya Empire-284 BCE [1:57] Delhi Sultanate (Tughlaq)-1345 [8:45] Mughal Empire-1692 [10:24] As for 'they also brought manufactured goods back', they exported raw materials from India and imported back finished goods, thereby destroying… — nonamechicken, 2021-11

Related videos