I have APHANTASIA (and you may too...without realising it!)

Channel:JAMIEvstheVOID · Length:12:54 · Published:2018-10-09 · Views:7972445

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An artist describes discovering she has aphantasia, the inability to form mental images, and how it affects her work. She asks viewers about their own visualization.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to it as a vivid first-person description of aphantasia and an example of an aphantasic artist.

this video is fantastic for describing the feeling of aphantasia — HN, 2019

Neuroscience & the brain · Consciousness & cognition

Subtitles (excerpt)

let's do something a little against the grain I'd like to kick this video off with a quick little visual experiment so sit back relax close your eyes if you want to and I want you to think of an apple so you're thinking of this Apple in your mind where is this Apple is it floating in space is it suspended on a tree is it in your hand is it in fruitball are you seeing it in first-person does it look like it has a stalk or a leaf attached now imagine changing color of that Apple how does it feel can you imagine that how how shiny is it can you rotate it 180 degrees in your mind can you put it say in different lighting settings like if it was in daytime put it in a dark nighttime setting what would it look like if you took a bite out of it try to make these images in your head as bright and vivid as you can and hold it that really see it okay if you did close your eyes you can open them now although you may have missed out on some sick animation no you didn't don't worry you didn't miss much okay so on a scale of zero to ten zero representing seeing absolutely no image in your head and 10 being absolutely vivid almost like it were real so what do you personally fall on the scale giving you time to answer all right if you survive that

On Hacker News

A little slow, but this video is fantastic for describing the feeling of aphantasia and it's sort of doubly fascinating that the incredibly talented artist who made it suffers from it (as I'm the flip side, great at visualizing and horrid at creation) [VIDEO] — michaelbuckbee, 2019-06
So I have aphantasia, and I first realized when talking to someone about mental images and memories. They have photorealistic pictures in their mind, or even video scenes like a movie. At my best I have something like an expressionist painting with words and concepts arranged spatially on blobs of color representing the object. More typically, just blackness. Here is another description of it, an… — cybersol, 2019-01
It's hard! There are some professional artists who are aphantasic, e.g. this YouTube video talks about it [VIDEO] IIRC, the artist does lots of sketches, and looks at them to see what looks right. And also uses computer models to get angles of what she's drawing which she struggles with otherwise. — frabcus, 2023-10

Related videos