Is Your Red The Same as My Red?

Channel:Vsauce · Length:9:34 · Published:2013-02-17 · Views:34054688

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Vsauce explores qualia and whether different people experience colors the same way. It draws on color blindness, Mary's room, the explanatory gap and subjective experience.

Why HN recommends it

HN points people to it as an accessible explanation of what qualia are.

Vsauce did a good video on it — HN, 2020

Neuroscience & the brain · Consciousness & cognition · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

Hey, Vsauce. Michael here. This appears blue. This appears yellow. And this appears green. Those of us with normal color vision can probably agree. But that doesn't change the fact that color is an illusion. Color, as we know it, does not exist in the outside world, beyond us, like gravity or protons do. Instead, color is created inside our heads. Our brains convert a certain range of the electromagnetic spectrum into color. I can measure the wavelength of radiation, but I can't measure or observe the experience of a color inside your mind. So, how do I know that when you and me look at a strawberry, and, in my brain, this perception occurs, which I call "red," that, in your brain, a perception like this doesn't occur, which you have, of course, also learned to call red. We both call it red. We communicate effectively and walk away, never knowing just how different each of our internal experiences really were. Of course, we already know that not everybody sees color in exactly the same way. One example would be color blindness. But we can diagnose and discuss these differences because people with the conditions fail to see things that most of us can. Conceivably though, there could be ways of

On Hacker News

You might be interested in the concept of qualia [0] Vsauce did a good video on it, "Is Your Red The Same as My Red?" [1] 0: [LINK] 1: [VIDEO] — behindsight, 2020-06
For anyone who read this comment and was wondering what "qualia" actually is, I found an old episode of VSause about it: [VIDEO] . — 0xdeadb00f, 2019-08
I expected this to be about the question whether your perception of blue might be like my perception of red. [1] [1] [VIDEO] — danbruc, 2024-09
well different people have different retinas, how are you going to make sure there is a universally agreed representation, of a colored trademark =p [VIDEO] — mygo, 2018-11

Related videos