I Did Caffeine Analysis: Some Unexpected Results!

Channel:James Hoffmann · Length:18:42 · Published:2022-12-12 · Views:1751667

Watch on YouTube

Summary

James Hoffmann runs caffeine analyzer tests comparing filter versus espresso, extraction over time, steep time, instant coffee and light versus dark roast.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as measured evidence of how brew method affects caffeine content, notably that filter coffee extracts more than espresso.

Check out this James Hoffmann video specifically on this topic — HN, 2024

Cooking & food

Subtitles (excerpt)

- Today we're gonna bust some caffeine myths. Now recently a company called Lighttells made a relatively inexpensive caffeine analyzer and so immediately I had to buy it. It's in here. Now I say relatively because it was still around $2,500, but that's cheaper than anything else I've seen. Now the reason I was so interested to get it is because there's been loads of studies on caffeine, but honestly, most of the time I haven't really trusted either the quality of coffee they were brewing or the quality of brewing that they were measuring. And suddenly I could do a bunch of tests and ask a bunch of questions and get a bunch of real answers that are relevant to me and the coffee that I drink and the coffee that you drink at home or in cafes every day. First of all, I'll show you how this machine works 'cause it is kind of interesting and then we'll get into the really fascinating stuff. We're gonna cover things from instant coffee to espresso brewing to roast levels and there are some surprises in this whole thing. This is it. I know it doesn't look like $2,500, it doesn't look very exciting, but I promise you it is. The way it works is kind of annoying, if we're honest. Turn it on. That bit's fine and I'll connect to it with my phone in a second.

On Hacker News

Prep method matters so much though. For comparison, a standard double shot of espresso is typically 18g of coffee. This would yield approximately 110mg of caffeine. By comparison, the same 18g brewed using a pour over method should yield an 8oz cup of coffee with … likely around 170mg of caffeine. Check out this James Hoffmann video specifically on this topic: [VIDEO] — Kirby64, 2024-02
1 cup filter coffee can be 170mg or more. And LD50 isn’t really relevant here, even LD1 levels are deadly to hundreds of millions of people. It’s entirely possible for what some might consider a “normal” amount of coffee to be deadly to many. See other comment for espresso calculations. [VIDEO] — aphantastic, 2024-12
Not necessarily true, filter extracts more caffeine than espresso at the same soluble extraction levels: [VIDEO] The truth is there is not enough scientific research to compare all brewing methods. Espresso uses high pressure but very short brew times, but filter uses more water and longer brew times therefore the coffee comes out totally different, and that's before we even talk about different … — FirmwareBurner, 2023-08

Related videos