Khan Academy and the Effectiveness of Science Videos

Channel:Veritasium · Length:8:04 · Published:2011-03-17 · Views:1689064

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Veritasium examines research suggesting science explainer videos like Khan Academy's make students feel they understand while tests show they have not learned, because misconceptions go unaddressed. It suggests how to partly fix this.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it in debates on video-based teaching and how confronting misconceptions helps learning, though some find its Khan Academy critique flawed.

please watch the whole video because it explains one massive problem with video science lessons and how to partially fix the problem. — HN, 2011

Education & learning · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

I want to talk about Con Academy if you haven't heard of it you should uh definitely check it out one guy uh s KH has made uh thousands of videos over 2,200 at the moment uh on everything from uh math to uh history and uh also quite a few videos about science and uh there are a lot of things to love about uh Con Academy first of all everything's freely available through YouTube um Khan's goal is to uh improve the education for all students and he is an exceptional teacher uh an absolutely fantastic uh speaker he also emphasizes Mastery which I think is very important so um students in the program can only move on after uh completing 10 questions in a row correctly and he's also developed some activities and software and he's working with schools to try to humanize the classroom to try to um uh help improve the quality of student teacher time and he's pushing uh the learning well beyond uh the video area uh but I want to put that work aside for a moment and uh just focus on the millions of viewers who watch his science videos online you see I'm skeptical that they actually promote some meaning meanful learning and that's not just a comment about Khan's videos but a comment on science videos in general so let me explain that skepticism

On Hacker News

Founder of StudyWand.com here, who received a 15k grant to develop an AI generating flashcard app in 2020 after an earlier prototype. We've found students more consistently study ready-made cards that are at desirable difficulty (they get about 80% correct) and which are segmented by topic (e.g. semantic grouping of flashcards to tackle "one lesson at a time" like Duolingo). Students would prefer… — james-revisoai, 2023-02
Well if you want to pay great teachers to produce science videos, I would start by offering this guy a lot of money. Or at the very least, please watch the whole video because it explains one massive problem with video science lessons and how to partially fix the problem. [VIDEO] — joshg, 2011-06
Some of the teachers I have worked with do this; and there are some great teachers(lecturers) like Martin who teach effective studying techniques: [LINK] Flashcards and Anki were incredibly effective for me. I am building a study tool which automatically generates them from lecture slides. Beyond that, it applies other psychology of learning techniques - It breaks up content into manageable chunk… — james-revisoai, 2024-08
This makes some great points, and Martin Lombell has covered something very similar in a rather timeless one hour engaging lecture here: [LINK] Some other diamonds I've uncovered or found while working on learning psychology are: - that students who organise fun and exercise on their schedule before studying, get better grades than the students who start by deciding when to study; - that most of … — james-revisoai, 2024-02
"Plays into common misconceptions" is one of the worst properties that a video targeted at general audiences can have. This even happens if your video is technically correct but sounds sorta like the common misconception [1]. Someone who watched the Dr. Quantum video has learned a bunch of keywords and phrases associated with quantum mechanics. They've now heard of waves and particles and detecto… — Strilanc, 2023-01

Related videos