The Battle of the Diets: Is Anyone Winning (At Losing?)

Channel:Stanford · Length:1:16:43 · Published:2008-05-23 · Views:309067

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Stanford's Christopher Gardner presents his large, long comparison of four popular diets under real-world conditions, in which the lowest-carbohydrate Atkins diet came out on top.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as a researcher presenting actual diet-study results, including a trial with 311 women on different diet books.

Here's a researcher presenting the results of their study as well as discussing several others[1]. — HN, 2016

Nutrition & diet science

Subtitles (excerpt)

This program is brought to you by Stanford University. Please visit us at stanford.edu. I'm very informal speaker, so you can interrupt me anywhere along the way. If you get bored of my slides, you can ask me to stop and clarify any kind of questions. I did want to start and say that I actually had absolutely no interest in this topic to begin with. I'm a 25-year vegetarian. I run garlic trials, soy trials, vegetarian trials, ginkgo trials. And I'd go to research conferences or public speaking engagements like this, and I would finish my garlic talk, and I would ask if anyone wanted to know the putative active agent of garlic, and hands would go up, and they'd say, "No, but can I lose weight on Atkins?" And my whole talk was on garlic. Okay, anybody else? Yes, can I lose weight on the Zone? I said, it was a soy talk. Why do you want to know about weight loss? And I was very frustrated because there weren't really any studies to show that any of these things worked or not. There's actually a good reason why most people don't study these. They're fad diets. They go out of fashion so fast that from a researcher's perspective, I write a grant, it gets rejected, I resubmit, it gets rejected, I get

On Hacker News

There's a good (old) talk where Stanford's Christopher Gardner researched different diet books with 311 women. The Battle of the Diets: Is Anyone Winning (At Losing?) [VIDEO] The study was announced at [LINK] — scholia, 2017-07
To steal a line, dietary science is younger than it looks. Don't be surprised if decade spanning long held beliefs start collapsing. Another good video. Stanford nutritionist and self-described vegetarian admits benefits of low carb diets: [VIDEO] — jackchristopher, 2010-01
I haven't stayed up to date on the nutrition science stuff much, but there are studies showing that low carb, high fat diets (paleo, essentially) are better than the opposite. Here's a researcher presenting the results of their study as well as discussing several others[1]. Their study had 311 subjects, but most of the other studies the researcher mentions have extremely small sample sizes (one o… — toasterlovin, 2016-09
> High fat/high sugar foods offer the most calories/dollar. So what? Well, the theory is that cheap vegetable oil and sugar causes these metabolic disorders which then causes obesity. >Taubes' insulin theories have been debunked by experiments. They're not his theories. He makes the point repeatedly in GCBC that they form part of modern, standard biochemistry. The only controversial points that h… — backprojection, 2012-04

Related videos