Why are we changing maps? (from The West Wing)

Channel:SaltLakeUsersGroup · Length:3:58 · Published:2012-05-18 · Views:801140

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short clip from The West Wing in which staffers meet a group advocating the Peters projection and challenge the Mercator map. It was shown as geography humor at a Salt Lake GIS user group meeting.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it in any thread on map projections and the Mercator distortion of country sizes, often calling it a favorite scene.

my favorite scene from The West Wing — HN, 2021

Data visualization & information design · Film & TV clips · Visual arts, photography & architecture

Subtitles (excerpt)

hi I'm sorry oh sorry to be late not a problem I'm CJ Craig of course you are I'm Dr John phow this Dr Cynthia Sals and Professor Donald huke huke huke okay and you are the organization of cartographers for social equality well we're we're from the ocsc we have many members how many 4,300 du's pay Members what are the dues $20 a year for the newsletter let's start wait wait I want to see this this is Josh Lyman indeed you are Josh this is Dr fow and who's Mary men yes should we begin yes plain and simple uh we'd like President Bartlett to aggressively support legislation that would make it mandatory for every public school in America to teach geography using the Peters projection map instead of the traditional Mercer give me 200 bucks and it's done really no why are we changing Maps uh because CJ the Mercer projection has fostered European imperialist attitudes for centuries and created an ethnic bias against the third world really the German cartographer Mercer originally designed this map in 1569 as a navigational tool for European Sailors the map enlarges areas at the poles to create straight lines of constant bearing or Geographic Direction so it makes it easier to cross an ocean but yes it distorts the relative size of Nations and

On Hacker News

Coincidentally, yesterday I saw (again) “The West Wing” scenes[1] that express this problem (and the related social issues). It was the first learned about map projections and I think if they aren’t already an explicit topic in school, they ought to be. I find it very interesting. [1] [VIDEO] — sircastor, 2024-05
There was a memorable scene from "The West Wing" on the biases imposed by most map projections, in particular, how Mercator makes North America look huge: [VIDEO] — randcraw, 2023-06
This reminds me of my favorite scene from The West Wing where they talk about how misleading the Mercator projection is with regard to the size of Africa. [VIDEO] — gundmc, 2021-05
Same here. I do remember the famous scene from West Wing which lead me to research the topic. Scene here: [VIDEO] — casefields, 2022-08
Hopefully, yes. Also hilarious how even on this downward trajectory the liberal order's main propaganda entities (like the FT here) run with geeky and nerdy stuff like charts (?!), that will show 'em!! A true sign that they know nothing of the real (ideological world). Just the other day they (the FT, that is) were also running with that mantra of "Trump is invading Greenland only on account of h… — paganel, 2026-01

Related videos