THE DUMBEST BOY ALIVE. PRETTY GOOD, EPISODE SIX.

Channel:Jon Bois · Length:18:12 · Published:2016-02-18 · Views:1623205

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Jon Bois tells the story of a 2008 bodybuilding forum thread in which users spent a weekend arguing over how many days are in a week. It is episode six of his Pretty Good series for SB Nation.

Why HN recommends it

Shared as the definitive retelling of one of the dumbest online arguments ever.

Jon Bois did an amazing video about this one — HN, 2025

Internet culture & memes · Documentaries & storytelling

Subtitles (excerpt)

8 years ago there was a discussion on a message board it was active for 2 days and then it was locked since then it's been viewed more than 3 million times so listen I never posted on this forum I don't know any of these people but it's a story I have to talk about it is the dumbest internet fight I have ever seen this is a thread from a bodybuilding.com message board it was recently Unearthed by Reddit and it dates back to May of 2008 it starts on a Friday afternoon when a guy asks whether it's safe to do a full body workout every other day fair question right someone answers yeah it's pretty much fine and he answers back are you sure four to five times a week isn't overtraining four to five times a week let's just draw that out real quick all right Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday cat dog okay there we go yep five times couple other nice folks show up and chip in yeah yeah don't worry about it every other day is fine and then Stevie km3 shows up wait he says that doesn't make sense if you go every other day you couldn't possibly go five times in a week that's three and a half times a week hold on let me uh draw this up 7 divided by two yep three and a half times he's right the Josh answers back

On Hacker News

> Obligatory post about the dumbest argument to ever be had online Jon Bois did an amazing video about this one: [VIDEO] — wolrah, 2025-04
LEMMiNO has a nice 18 minutes documentary and summary on Cicada 3301: [LINK] -- Some "internet lore" off the top of my head: * Body builders try to figure out how many days are in a week, summary dramatised here: [VIDEO] * Time Cube: [LINK] -- EDIT: speaking of SilvaGunner, I've never heard this name before, I found two mentions of it on two unrelated YouTube videos in the past 3 hours. Incredibl… — 1_player, 2021-05
Hm, if they switched the schedule up a little and had a workout every other day (with a rest day in between) they could have been working out 4-5 times per week. If anyone's unsure about the maths on that then don't worry, "you don't count the day you're on when you're counting days " ;-) [VIDEO] — smcl, 2022-09

Related videos