Why Koko (Probably) Couldn't Talk (Sorry) | The Deep Dive

Channel:Soup Emporium · Length:49:12 · Published:2021-05-05 · Views:3848334

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A long video essay arguing that Koko the gorilla probably could not actually use sign language. It examines the cherry-picked data and the lack of transparency behind the claims, drawing on published critiques.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as a thorough debunking of Koko's supposed language ability in threads about animal communication.

While this video is long, it explains the controversy very well — HN, 2022

Animals & nature · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

[The gentle creaks of an old, haunted library. Ooooo! Spoopy!] So I've been collecting notes on topics for a good couple years. According to Google docs, I've been collecting notes on Koko since 2018. But I've only recently started making videos for YouTube. So when I dusted this script off to double check it, I'd found out that Michael Hobbs and Sarah Marshall already did a koko episode on their excellent podcast, You're wrong about. And, uh, well, without spoiling anything, they talk about the same stuff that I wanted to. So if this video sounds similar to their podcast, it's-- it's cuz it is. Um, we're all drawing from the same well. But I've been collecting notes on things for too long to shelve this project now! Koko the gorilla couldn't talk! [MOOP 2:] Wait, what, what do you mean Koko couldn't tal-- BWAHH! [*splash!*] [♫ Descent by Autumnmnmn ♫] [SOUP:] Okay. So. I talk to my cat. I'll give her love and affections and I'll narrate tasks to her and I'll scold her when she leaves a plate of chicken that I cooked for, even though it's crispy on the outside and soft in the middle, which is exactly how she likes it. But why do I talk to my cat? More broadly, why do we talk to animals? Even *more* broadly,

On Hacker News

You may want to watch this video: [VIDEO] Human language is way above what communication animals show. We don't really know what's the exact boundary, but again, the difference is significant and not just "scaled up". — gf000, 2026-03
Here's a great video about the extreme cherry picking and lack of transparency it takes to argue that Koko had any better of an understanding of language than a well trained dog: [VIDEO] — dlcarrier, 2025-02
I’m skeptical of this. This sounds similar to the way Koko “learned” sign language. While this video is long, it explains the controversy very well: [VIDEO] — expensive_news, 2022-04
The article casually mentions Koko, and it's a bit sad that the story of Koko's "language" is still alive... I can not remember book exceprt, but recently there was a great video about Koko [VIDEO] — galkk, 2021-10
> Note that Koko was obviously a greater communicator than any parrot ever was. Sadly, I don't think this is actually true, despite the popular belief. See [VIDEO] TL;DW - Data was VERY cherry-picked to make it look like she could communicate via sign language. At best, she was responding via rote memorization and had no idea what she was actually communicating. — Sohcahtoa82, 2023-04

Related videos