The Suburban Traffic Contradiction

Channel:Oh The Urbanity! · Length:8:43 · Published:2021-10-09 · Views:177402

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Oh The Urbanity! questions the framing that urban planning reforms like bike lanes and traffic calming wage war on suburbanites. It argues that suburban and urban residents alike want less traffic on their own streets.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in urbanism threads as a clear argument that car-dependent suburbs impose traffic on everyone.

This video makes that point so crystal clear — HN, 2021

Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

This is Los Altos Hills, a wealthy suburban town of 8,500 people in the San Francisco Bay Area that was in the news a few years ago over its fight with navigation app Waze. Los Altos Hills was one of many suburbs across North America concerned that Waze was sending too much outsider traffic through their quiet residential streets. In some cases, residents fabricated reports of traffic accidents on the app to send a signal that their neighbourhood is closed. On one hand, all of this is understandable. Cars are dangerous, loud, and they pollute. Having a lot of traffic through your neighbourhood degrades your quality of life in meaningful ways, including threatening your kids’ ability to be independent and play outside. Residents on certain roads that saw sharp increases in traffic reported being afraid to cross the road to get their mail. On the other hand, it’s hard not to notice a certain contradiction. At the same time that they’re fighting to keep other people’s traffic away from their neighbourhood, Los Altos Hills is literally built to generate traffic for other neighbourhoods. There is no grocery store within the borders of this 9 square mile or 23 square kilometre town—in fact, there are very nearly no stores at all,

On Hacker News

Yes, cul-de-sacs are a design element that can help to reduce the negative impacts of cars - in the immediate area. Though if you build an area out of cul-de-sacs with no bike/pedestrian shortcuts, you end up not being able to practically get around without a car, so the area around the cul-de-sacs needs lots of car infrastructure. (Which is not so great if your kids are unlucky enough to live ac… — ryukafalz, 2024-07
Correct. Suburbanites want the freedom to drive everywhere but also limit through-traffic and noise on the street their house exists on. That's why twisty roads and culs de sac exist. "Oh The Urbanity!" argues this point elegantly in: [VIDEO] "The Suburban Traffic Contradiction" — nayuki, 2023-04
There's a good video explaining how urban and suburban residents alike want less traffic in their neighborhoods: [VIDEO] — nayuki, 2022-01
Exactly. This video makes that point so crystal clear: [VIDEO] Car-dependent suburbia is about imposing your car on everyone else while not allowing anyone else to impose their cars on you. It is inherently selfish city design. — joshlemer, 2021-11
There's a great video about that too. "The Suburban Traffic Contradiction" by Oh The Urbanity. [VIDEO] One of the interesting points is that there is a commonality between those suburbans and people who want walkable urban areas: few of us want to deal with the problems of lots of cars driving around us. — drivers99, 2021-11

Related videos