Akira Kurosawa - Composing Movement
Channel:Every Frame a Painting · Length:8:24 · Published:2015-03-20 · Views:10830543
Summary
An Every Frame a Painting video essay on how Akira Kurosawa used movement, weather and composition to tell stories. It draws on clips and interviews with other filmmakers.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters recommend it as a deeply researched example of film analysis and one of the most educational videos on YouTube.
check out the wonderful commentary by 'Every Frame a Painting' — HN, 2020
Filmmaking & video production · Film analysis & criticism
Subtitles (excerpt)
Hi my name is Tony and this is Every Frame a Painting. So here’s a fundamental question: When you’re judging a shot, what’s the first thing you look for? Is it balance? Leading lines? Golden ratio? Color? Light? Shapes? I think these are all essential, and they’re all part of good images. But there’s one thing I always notice first Movement --For me, Kurosawa is the Beethoven of movie directors --It's that recognizable full sound that Beethoven had --that is so unmistakable A Kurosawa film moves like no one else’s Each one is a masterclass in different types of motion and also ways to combine them. Over a career spanning half a century he made 30 films and in all of them, the movement is surprising and cinematic. Wow. If you’d like to see the names of the films, press the CC button below. So what types of movement did he like? First, there’s the movement of nature. In every one of his films, the background of the shot features some kind of weather. Wind Water Fire Smoke Snow One advantage of this approach is that shots have a lot of visual interest. Even when people are still, there’s rain in the background to draw your eye. --Rain is a real emotional trigger that works in any film.
On Hacker News
If you havne't already done so, check out the wonderful commentary by 'Every Frame a Painting': [VIDEO] (Composing Movement) [LINK] (The Geometry of a Scene) I don't normally recommend YouTube channels for film commentary, but this channel is very good indeed. — Daub, 2020-06
What I love about Every Frame a Painting is the depth of its research. It's quite clear that the creators had an extensive knowledge of film. The videos always include wonderfully selected interviews with the filmmakers that emphasize the point far more than just a person talking. The Deakins interview in Shot | Reverse Shot taken from Cinematographer Style is a nice example^[1]. Or Sidney Lumet'… — _hardwaregeek, 2019-09
Part of this, I think, is also the shift to dialogue-based scripts. It reminds me of this excellent Every Frame a Painting video that compares Kurosawa’s effective use of movement with the barely-moving, dialogue-driven Avengers films. A huge percentage of films/shows today are what Hitchcock called, “photographs of people talking” and aren’t actually cinematic. If they were more cinematic, heari… — keiferski, 2023-08
I think we're sort of aggressively agreeing with each other. It's not the CGI (or lack thereof) that makes the modern superhero films bad (except as a sort of demoscene-with-infinite-budget visual spectacle where they're great). It's the writing. To a lesser extent the cinematography is poor, which makes it hard to really feel what's going on. There's lots of unnecessary camera movement, frenetic… — SAI_Peregrinus, 2022-02
Selected Twitter responses: - Why Planes Don't Fly Faster, [LINK] - Akira Kurosawa - Composing Movement, [VIDEO] - Richard Hamming: "Learning to Learn", [LINK] - Rise and fall of Third Reich, [LINK] - The men who built America, [LINK] -History of the World, [LINK] — yarapavan, 2019-04
Related videos
- Compiling C to printable x86, to make an executable research paper · suckerpinch · 25:41
- Dani DaOrtiz at Fool US 2022 (the act that Penn and Teller didn’t even try to figure out.) · dani daortiz · 10:29
- Steve Jobs Secrets of Life · Silicon Valley Historical Association · 1:40
- Neuromancer (BBC radio play adaptation ) William Gibson · Michael McGrath · 1:56:54
- Buster Keaton - The Art of the Gag · Every Frame a Painting · 8:34
- Why Planes Don't Fly Faster · Wendover Productions · 11:32
- Jackie Chan - How to Do Action Comedy · Every Frame a Painting · 9:04
- Everything is a Remix (Original Series) · Kirby Ferguson · 37:30
- "NO CGI" is really just INVISIBLE CGI - 1 · The Movie Rabbit Hole · 16:30
- The Marvel Symphonic Universe · Every Frame a Painting · 13:35
- The Spectacular Failure of the Star Wars Hotel · Jenny Nicholson · 4:05:39
- Vancouver Never Plays Itself · Every Frame a Painting · 9:06
- The Fall of The Simpsons: How it Happened · Super Eyepatch Wolf · 31:08
- Blender Motion Tracking - Room Transformation! · IanHubert · 7:57
- Pink Floyd Echoes & 2001 A Space Odyssey HD · barrettproduction · 23:35
- Flight of the Navigator | VFXcool · Captain Disillusion · 41:28