Music Software & Bad Interface Design: Avid’s Sibelius

Channel:Tantacrul · Length:21:35 · Published:2018-11-15 · Views:1744647

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Tantacrul dissects the UX and UI of Avid's Sibelius music notation software, going through a long list of bad design choices. The review is both a comic rant and a practical lesson in interface design.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as the most entertaining serious critique of a software interface, and a crash course in UX mistakes.

might be the most entertaining serious critique of a software user interface ever posted to YouTube. — HN, 2020

UX & UI design · Music theory, synthesis & production

Subtitles (excerpt)

Sibelius is truly revolutionary, ...in the sense that, ...no matter how carefully you try to work with it, ...it always seems to be trying to rise up against you. It's hard to learn, ...poorly maintained, ...and sports a navigation system that seems to take pride in ...putting things where you'd least expect them. And that's going to be our design focus for this video: The subtleties of designing a navigation for a complex program. And, disclaimer: Although this will initially start like a pretty down-to-earth, ...reasonable design analysis, ...like my last video about Propellerhead's Reason, Sibelius has a particularly unique ability ...to drive me actually insane. So I'll keep it together as long as I can, ...but don't be surprised if I go slightly off the rails at some point. You have been warned. So, in case you're new to this channel, ...I'm a composer and also a software designer, ...which is why I find Sibelius particularly frustrating, ...since it's got some genius functionality in there ...that I make use of on a daily basis, ...but which is obstructed from flourishing ...by its bafflingly haphazard design. So what's wrong with it? [shudders] And how did it get this way? So, Sibelius was created by twin brothers ...Ben and Jonathan Finn.

On Hacker News

If anyone is yet to see it, Tantacrul (on youtube) is now deeply involved with MuseScore (UX lead or similar?); he put out an awesome vid on the design of MS4 at the beginning of the year: [LINK] His video on how Sibelius' UX is a pile of shit remains one of my favourite vids on yt: [VIDEO] — l__l, 2023-07
Since Sibelius and Finale are two industry-leading (and very much competing) music notation software systems, this headline made me do a quadruple-take! [LINK] [LINK] For those interested in (extremely entertaining) breakdowns of the Sibelius software and other offerings in this space from a UI/UX design perspective, I highly recommend Tantacrul's videos, which propelled him to becoming the head … — btown, 2021-10
OSS needs more UI/UX people, and I think Tantacrul is fantastic for this. His twitter ( [LINK] ) and youtube ( [LINK] ) are full of interesting tidbits, an you can tell he's passionate about things. Even if you don't do music/notation his video on Sibelius, [VIDEO] , is ridiculously funny, but also on point. — wexq, 2021-05
The cheese melts in the microwave; the music melts in Sibelius. Tantacrul’s review of Sibelius’ might be the most entertaining serious critique of a software user interface ever posted to YouTube. [VIDEO] — sjwright, 2020-06
Obligatory funny video review of MuseScore 3 UI: [LINK] Same author also has a funny video on the UI of another music notation program, Sibelius: [VIDEO] — radicality, 2022-12

Related videos