Julia: to Lisp or not to Lisp?

Channel:European Lisp Symposium · Length:1:04:53 · Published:2016-05-30 · Views:23615

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Stefan Karpinski's European Lisp Symposium 2016 talk asks whether Julia is a Lisp. He covers the features it borrows from Lisp, such as macros and closures, and where it departs, including syntax and its type system, with generated machine code shown.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as a brilliant talk on Julia's design and how it is or isn't a Lisp.

the recent brilliant talk about design of Julia — HN, 2016

Programming language design · Functional programming

Subtitles (excerpt)

all right at the risk of being a little bit less imposing I'm going to sit down because I'm gonna I'm G to be typing a lot during this presentation can everybody see this fairly clearly all right great um so I entitled this somewhat whim whimsically uh Julia to lisp or not to lisp um you know there's people have uh thrown around claims that uh Ruby is an adequate lisp and JavaScript is really basically lisp um Julia was very much inspired by lisp uh specifically scheme but uh also also other for varieties of lisp um and there's a little Easter egg that I'll actually demo at the very end but um I'm not I'm not going to do a point-to-point comparison because I think that's just not that interesting so I'm just going to talk about a lot of the interesting features and I think you guys will be able to see for yourselves where the similarities and differences are uh and then we can discuss it at the end um so I'm going to start out with an observation about numer Americal programming languages which are this sort of funny idiosyncratic lot of languages which uh one of my co-founders put into this graphic here at some point which is supposed to be roughly proportional to their popularity are mat lab those are the

On Hacker News

This reminded me of the recent brilliant talk about design of Julia: "Julia: to lisp or not to lisp?" [VIDEO] — e12e, 2016-06
Ah, the Julia talk ( [VIDEO] ) was just great. Showing the generated machine code is so hackerish yet so rare these days. :-/ — Flow, 2016-05
Stefan Karpinski (one of the core Julia contributors) gave a talk (in 2016, so rather dated as far as the Julia syntax and whatnot go) about how Julia is secretly more lisp-y than even lisp & Scheme. The core of this argument is that most language specifications dedicate many pages to defining how arithmetic works, whereas Julia is actually just able to define that in Julia code as part of the st… — travisd, 2022-09
I'm a great admirer of Julia, but I doubt it would appeal to those seeking a "true" lisp/scheme. Even if it's has a sane macro system, and much of the same power. You can indeed see s-expressions (search for "s-expression") : [LINK] This nice talk mentions a bit on how Julia is (not) a lisp (if I recall correctly): "Julia: to Lisp or not to Lisp?": [VIDEO] This might also be of interest: [LINK] A… — e12e, 2018-11
You might also want to have a look at Julia. It's not really a lisp, but it sits on top of a scheme - and it has a rather interesting, pragmatic type system: "Julia: to lisp or not to lisp?": [VIDEO] [LINK] Maybe compare and contrast with Maxima?: [LINK] — e12e, 2018-05

Related videos