Does It Make Sense To Put Data Centers In Space? Can They Really Cost Less To Operate?

Channel:Scott Manley · Length:16:36 · Published:2024-09-09 · Views:505083

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Scott Manley analyzes the idea of putting data centers in orbit, prompted by Lumen Orbit's funding. He examines the claimed advantage of constant solar power against launch cost, cooling and mass.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended in orbital data center threads as a sober explanation of why the idea doesn't work out economically or thermally.

The great Scott Manley did a video about that — HN, 2025

Cloud, DevOps & reliability · Space exploration & spaceflight

Subtitles (excerpt)

hello it's Scott Manley here this week a small Silicon Valley startup called Lumen orbit published a white K paper entitled why we should train AI in orbit their pitch is they want to put data centers in space in their paper they do some back of the envelope math which explains why they think that data centers in space are the way forward for giant compute jobs such as training AI data sets now they are by no means the first people to suggest putting data centers in space but they are the ones that have been given a couple of million dollars by investors saying that maybe this could actually turn into something and as a Silicon Valley Tech person myself I was surprised to see that the people backing this are why combinator a you know Tech accelerator startup that's been responsible for companies such as Reddit twitch door Dash Airbnb and while that is an impressive pedigree you have to remember this is the world of venture capital and for every big success that comes out of one of these you're going to have nine companies that didn't quite make it and I will be completely unsurprised if Lumen orbit is one of those nine that fail but they are all about space flight and I'm really interested in talking about this so what is

On Hacker News

The great Scott Manley did a video about that: [VIDEO] basically it doesn't make sense with current technologiesa and even with Starship's proposed specs/price it won't be profitable. Check it out... — freefaler, 2025-12
Scott Manley had a video about this last year. [VIDEO] The short of it is that cooling is likely the biggest problem, given you will need to pump the heat to the backside and radiate it away, and the amount of mass you will need to dedicate to cooling works against deployments and increases the cost per unit significantly. Not to mention, the idea of these huge deployments runs into potential spa… — Ataraxic, 2025-12
Scott Manley has published a video a few months ago explaining why putting data centers in space is an absolutely terrible idea. Lumen Orbit, the company mentioned, is a former name of Starcloud. [VIDEO] — shantara, 2025-05
If you want to see exactly the type of solar panels needed for a data center (and why they’re impractical in even ideal situations) then check out this mockup of a proposed space data center ran off solar: [VIDEO] — tourmalinetaco, 2024-09

Related videos