Run containers on bare metal already!
Channel:Bryan Cantrill · Length:41:12 · Published:2015-11-13 · Views:40464
Summary
Bryan Cantrill's Velocity NYC 2015 talk argues for running containers directly on bare metal rather than layering them on virtual machines. He covers the history of containers and how SmartOS runs Linux workloads via syscall emulation.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters recommend it as an engaging and informative explanation of why containers on VMs waste resources and hurt performance.
he's an extremely engaging speaker, so not only are you likely to watch all of that 40 minute talk — HN, 2017
Operating systems & kernels · Cloud, DevOps & reliability
Subtitles (excerpt)
I want to talk about containers um if you're doing the container drinking game at velocity I assume you're already pretty well drunk um and if you're not bombed out of your mind you manage to crawl in here this morning you may want to fill up your drink cuz we're going to be doing a lot of containers it's going to be container container container all the time but for that let's turn the history dial back as I as I want to do uh let's look at container prehistory where did containers come from and uh containers and actually the great thing about containers is kind of like the The Mystery of the world we don't totally know so containers emerged with chero um with BSD back in the day so chero if you've used cho cho allows you to say have a directory in a file system and to have this directory act as the new root directory you virtualize the file system in in effect and sounds like a great idea where did it come from well we know that Bill Joy put it back we know that Bill Joy according to the secs history um Bill Joy put this back on March 18th 1982 we don't know why and when I say we don't know why Kirk doesn't exactly know why and I don't think Bill necessarily knows why and it's like it's the80s it's Berkeley I mean the the
On Hacker News
SmartOS's LX branded zones seem kind of cool to me, and may hit an interest point for you. Basically, SmartOS is an OpenSolaris variant where they use Solaris Zones for docker images, but they've implemented a Linux syscall table API so you can create Linux "compatible" containers from a Solaris kernel (and also full access to ZFS, etc). You can see a talk here[1] where Bryan Cantrill goes over t… — kbenson, 2017-11
It's all just history now for all I know, but there was work in the past to make Linux containers work on a Solaris fork (SmartOS, specifically) by emulating the Linux syscall table and presenting that to the containers. Joyent did work on this (alas, and there's an excellent and entertaining talk from Bryan Cantrill[1] that goes over it. I imagine FreeBSD could do something similar if they aren'… — kbenson, 2025-11
I have run containers on bare metal and in Amazon. Performance can be noticeably slower in Amazon on machines with similar specifications. A detailed explanation why is in this informative video by Bryan Cantrill [VIDEO] . It is a talk about how layering containers on top of virtual machines is a recipe for poor performance and wasted resource utilization. He equates it to developers “being given… — dpeterson, 2015-11
Unikernels : hypervisor :: processes : traditional operating system Joyent CTO Bryan Cantrill gave a great talk at Velocity NYC 2015 about the history of containers (going back to March 18, 1982 when Bill Joy added the chroot system call) and the problems of running containers on operating systems in VMs on hypervisors: "Stop killing kittens and melthing the ice caps: Run containers on bare metal… — cpeterso, 2015-11
The second I read "shared block cache" my brain went to containers. If you want data colocated on the same filesystem, then put it on the same filesystem. VMs suck, nobody spins up a whole fabricated IBM-compatible PC and gaslights their executable because they want to. [1] They do it because their OS (a) doesn't have containers, (b) doesn't provide strong enough isolation between containers, or … — drbawb, 2023-07
Related videos
- CppCon 2015: Chandler Carruth "Tuning C++: Benchmarks, and CPUs, and Compilers! Oh My!" · CppCon · 1:29:53
- Zebras All the Way Down - Bryan Cantrill, Uptime 2017 · Code & Supply · 46:36
- Principles of Technology Leadership | Bryan Cantrill | Monktoberfest 2017 · RedMonk Tech Events · 51:22
- Bryan Cantrill from Joyent on Manta: internet-facing object storage facility that features compute · AI Council · 1:31:05
- "Voice Driven Development: Who needs a keyboard anyway?" by Emily Shea · Strange Loop Conference · 41:17
- Maciej Ceglowski - Barely succeed! It's easier! · webdirections · 39:23
- The Material Science of Metal 3D Printing · Real Engineering · 14:59
- The Forgotten Art of Structured Programming - Kevlin Henney [C++ on Sea 2019] · cpponsea · 1:29:27
- GET LAMP: The Text Adventure Documentary · Google TechTalks · 2:01:17
- Classic Game Postmortem: Sid Meier's Civilization · GDC Festival of Gaming · 1:02:15
- Failing to Fail: The Spiderweb Software Way · GDC Festival of Gaming · 59:47
- "Stop Rate Limiting! Capacity Management Done Right" by Jon Moore · Strange Loop Conference · 42:20
- 'Oumuamua Is Not Aliens · PBS Space Time · 17:32
- Can C++ be 10x Simpler & Safer? - Herb Sutter - CppCon 2022 · CppCon · 1:53:59
- Can We Terraform the Sahara to Stop Climate Change? · Real Engineering · 12:48
- 'Diablo': A Classic Game Postmortem · GDC Festival of Gaming · 1:17:43