"A Political History of X" - Keith Packard (LCA 2020)

Channel:linux.conf.au · Length:45:33 · Published:2020-01-16 · Views:52557

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Keith Packard traces the 35-year history of the X Window System at linux.conf.au 2020. He uses X to examine licensing, corporate interests and community dynamics in free software, including Unix workstation vendors and Stallman's influence.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as the authoritative, firsthand account of how X came to be and why it isn't GPL.

I invite anyone interested by the subject to watch Keith Packard's amazing presentation on this at LCA 2020 — HN, 2022

Linux & open-source ecosystems · History of computing · Hacker culture & free software

Subtitles (excerpt)

reduce Keith's packet with the history of X well it's notionally history but it's really tales that I've told to a lot of people Bradley Kuhn actually encouraged me to put this talk together and submit it for his conference copyleft conf in a couple weeks in Brussels but as I was not planning on going to copy left off I said well I could submit that to LCA this talk was added late in the in the program due to some people not being able to attend and so it's a little rough around the edges so I apologize for that I usually like to spend a couple of months putting a talk together but this time I had about three days so here we go okay first off this is not a talk about anything my employer cares about it's definitely does not represent their opinions these are my opinions I need to tell you that because there is so there's going to be a lot of opinion in this and I will almost certainly be wrong for those of you who lived through this history please please feel free raise your hands and correct me or I do speak wrongly because 35 years of X is a long time and I'm sure I've forgotten most of the important things and as we all know now our memories tend to rewrite things as we tell stories to others and so this could be completely fictional okay who

On Hacker News

I invite anyone interested by the subject to watch Keith Packard's amazing presentation on this at LCA 2020: A Political History of X - [VIDEO] (can be listened without the video if you want to do other things while listening to it) — jraph, 2022-01
X11 did a lot of things. None of them "wrong", just "badly conjoined at the spinal cord". An X server is a fantastic example of how building drivers for deep hardware components should never have been written in userspace. (If anyone wants: There's a fantastic talk at LCA a few years ago from Keith Packard about X's history: [VIDEO] ) — indrora, 2024-08
Perhaps of some interest is "A Political History of X" by Keith Packard from the 2020 Linux Conference Australia (LCA): * [VIDEO] > Packard is responsible for many X extensions and technical papers on X. He has been heavily involved in the development of X since the late 1980s as a member of the MIT X Consortium, XFree86 and the X.Org Foundation. * [LINK] Goes over things from the early 1980s. — throw0101c, 2023-11
> X-Windows started out as one man's project in an office on the fifth floor of MIT's Laboratory for Computer Science. A wizardly hacker, who was familiar with W, a window system written at Stanford University as part of the V project, decided to write a distributed graphical display server. An overview of how this came to be: "A Political History of X" - Keith Packard (LCA 2020) [VIDEO] — pjmlp, 2020-03
> I also do not understand why anyone would drop the GPL because Stallman does not like their licensing. Because he can be so obnoxious that people want to sever all ties with him and anything that has to do with him so that they never ever have to talk to him ever again in any capacity. This goes back a long time. For example Keith Packard on why X11 isn't GPL (from [VIDEO] ): > Richard Stallman… — arp242, 2025-07

Related videos