D/A and A/D | Digital Show and Tell (Monty Montgomery @ xiph.org)
Channel:FL Studio · Length:23:52 · Published:2013-03-02 · Views:647430
Summary
Monty Montgomery of Xiph.org gives real-time demonstrations of sampling, quantization, bit depth and dither using real audio equipment, including both digital analysis tools and vintage analog bench gear. It shows that sampled audio is not stair-stepped and corrects common misconceptions about digital audio.
Why HN recommends it
HN calls it the gold-standard debunking of audiophile myths and the stair-step misconception, and recommends it as a primer on digital audio.
might be the best explanatory video I have ever witnessed — HN, 2018
Information theory & signal processing · Audio & video engineering
Subtitles (excerpt)
[Music] hi I'm Monty Montgomery from red hat and z.org a few months ago I wrote an article on digital audio and why 24bit 192 khz music downloads don't make sense in the article I mentioned almost in passing that a digital waveform is not a stair step and you certainly don't get a stair step when you convert from digital back to analog of everything in the entire article that was the number one thing people wrote about in fact more than half the mail I got was questions and comments about basic Digital Signal Behavior since there's interest let's take a little time to play with some simple digital signals pretend for a moment that we have no idea how digital signals really behave in that case it doesn't make sense for us to use digital test equipment either fortunately for this exercise there's still plenty of working analog lab equipment out there first up we need a signal generator to provide us with analog input signals in this case an HP 3325 from 1978 it's still a pretty good generator so if you don't mind the size the weight the power consumption and the noisy fan you can find them on eBay occasionally for only slightly more than you'll pay for shipping next we'll observe our analog waveforms on analog oscilloscopes like this tectronics
On Hacker News
@xiphmont also made an amazing video response to the many responses he received to this article. Using analog equipment he busts a bunch of myths and demonstrates what really happens with digital audio. [LINK] or on YT if you can't play it [VIDEO] — hackingonempty, 2026-07
This is the most lucid explanation of aliasing I think I've ever read. I mostly deal with this stuff in the realm of audio where the matter of analog vs digital rages regularly. The reason one hears "Nyquist says" so often from people defending digital audio is that the pro-analog people are imagining stair-stepped signals in which the information that is "lost" results in a noticeable degradatio… — sramsay, 2024-03
> Audiophiles might point out that analog audio sources can theoretically hold details you can't hear in digital. This is true because values in analog media are continuous. Over imperceptibly short periods of time, the numbers that represent different values on a sound wave in a digital recording jump instantaneously from one discrete value to another with no gentle slope between. Analog signals… — SeanLuke, 2023-01
[LINK] The talk [VIDEO] <-- Youtube backup in case it doesn't work (YMMV) I wish I could force any audiophiles to watch it before they waste their money on snake oil. I think a similar point can be made about analogue synthesis, e.g. You pay Moog £1500 for what is ultimately a fancy box for a relatively simple analogue circuit. — mhh__, 2019-07
Monty Montgomery's explanation of digital audio might be the best explanatory video I have ever witnessed, [VIDEO] — combatentropy, 2018-09
Related videos
- Dispelling the Myths of Nuclear Energy (Live Lecture) · Illinois EnergyProf · 35:50
- The Secret War · Sergio IQ · 4:55:45
- Edsger Dijkstra interview · Hans Otten · 24:04
- Grace Hopper Lecture · MIT Lincoln Laboratory · 1:25:56
- Bret Victor - Inventing on Principle · Rui Oliveira · 54:20
- John Carmack Facebook Connect 2021 Keynote · UploadVR · 1:01:32
- A Philosophy of Software Design | John Ousterhout | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:01:40
- Building my dream computer - Part 1 · The 8-Bit Guy · 20:37
- Fast Inverse Square Root — A Quake III Algorithm · Nemean · 20:08
- Hold music used to sound better. Here's why. · Tom Scott · 3:36
- Everything is a Remix (Original Series) · Kirby Ferguson · 37:30
- Micro Men - 720p (2009) · gimpymoo · 1:24:12
- What Really Happened at the Millennium Tower? · Practical Engineering · 13:32
- Yo-Yo Ma Bach Cello Suite No.1 in G Major · Thanyaphong Na nakorn · 18:19
- But what is the Fourier Transform? A visual introduction. · 3Blue1Brown · 19:41
- The Fast Fourier Transform (FFT): Most Ingenious Algorithm Ever? · Reducible · 28:23