1. A strange determinant

Channel:Timothy Gowers · Length:1:01:07 · Published:2021-04-22 · Views:30134

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Timothy Gowers thinks aloud, in real time, as he tries to understand why Pascal's determinant equals 1. He does not fully solve it in this episode, but shows his exploratory process.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it to see how a top mathematician approaches an unfamiliar problem through experiments and curiosity.

Gowers has one of my favourite video series about how he approaches a problem he is unfamiliar with — HN, 2026

Pure mathematics · Recreational & visual math

Subtitles (excerpt)

hello um i've decided to do a little experiment that's something i've been meaning to do for a long time which is to have a think about a maths problem in real time and video myself doing it uh and then make the video public um so why am i wanting to do that uh it's because it's always been a preoccupation of mine um how people think about proofs and how people find proofs how they solve maths problems and also how to teach the art of solving maths problems and i don't think there's a very easy answer to either question and so one of the best things one can do without having good answers to these things um there are better answers and worse answers but we have a truly satisfactory answer to the question so one of the things we can do is just have examples to look at um so in particular i think it may be useful for some people for some people that won't be useful at all but for some people it may be useful just to see somebody thinking about a math problem explaining what they're doing as they think um [Music] and i i making sort of saying things that that aren't particularly sensible realizing they're not sensible going down dead ends all that sort of thing so i'm taking a slight risk i'm going to think about a problem i've never thought about before i

On Hacker News

I’ll add to this to give an example of someone who I feel is doing a great job of satisfying this very request in the field of mathematics: Timothy Gowers. His yt channel is an excellent resource of theoretical understanding through numerical methods. Here’s my favorite series where he confirms/elucidates a “strange” theoretical fact with an explorative numerical style: [VIDEO] Simply superb cont… — mungal, 2022-04
Unfortunately Gowers has taken Tao's lead on this one. Gowers has one of my favourite video series about how he approaches a problem he is unfamiliar with: [VIDEO] It is disheartening to see him jump into this GenAI puffery. I hope these GenAI labs are paying Tao handsomely for legitimizing their slop, but more likely he's feeling pressure from his University to promote and work with these labs. … — missyougowers, 2026-05
But I do appreciate the comedy! Well while I have you, the message I feel I failed to adhere to in my comment was my interest in letting you, or others who follow their passion in math and programming, know that what you are doing is in fact “real” math! Keep it up! Your post made me click through a bunch of links in it. Thank you, but give me back that hour! ;P Better yet, I’ll trade you a diffe… — jrhvmt, 2024-04
> How would you solve a problem that no one has ever touched before, and that no one knows the answer to? Where are you going to be provided the answer? This is very near and dear to my heart. We are talking about “teaching” and I doubt anyone who supports the current education status quo is advocating to teach using unsolved problems. That said, I do feel, personally, and have long advocated for… — juniperror, 2024-02

Related videos