Locksmith ripoffs: Hidden camera investigation (Marketplace)

Channel:CBC News · Length:20:46 · Published:2020-01-11 · Views:21550027

Watch on YouTube

Summary

CBC Marketplace investigates locksmith scams in the Greater Toronto Area. It exposes networks of fake Google Maps listings and fake reviews, and uses hidden cameras to show how low quotes turn into overcharges.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as a concrete demonstration of how fake local business listings on Google Maps are used for scams.

This video has a demo of what is happening — HN, 2021

Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime · Law, policing & justice · Media, journalism & propaganda

Subtitles (excerpt)

[♪♪♪] [Makda] It's a chilly night in late November. And a woman sits in the middle of an emergency. I'm locked out of my place. [Makda] Help is on the way, she's told. But as we're about to find out... Hey! [man] Sorry about the wait. [Makda] There are no guarantees when you're picking a locksmith. The woman, in fact, is a Marketplace producer. And this house is a testing ground that we've rigged up with hidden cameras. Well, I think those all look pretty good. Yeah, it's pretty good. [Makda] Our plan is to call locksmiths over the next few nights. -There we go... -There, we know that one. Check Point Door and Lock. We've heard a lot about this one. [Makda] From companies we've heard might not give us a fair shake. It says $15-- 15 minute response time. [Makda] John Seitz is with us. He's got ten years experience as a locksmith, and we've hired him to help with our test. I wanna show you-- we've got some cameras set up. -[Makda] Let's go inside. -[John] Sounds good. [Makda] Together, we'll be in a back room... And if I just click here, we get a closer look. [John] Lovely. [Makda] Watching for signs of shoddy service, and much more. Like what happens to Dorothy Sterling. He just couldn't get the lock to work.

On Hacker News

This video has a demo of what is happening: [VIDEO] Essentially if you make a bunch of fake listings all around the State you work in people who are desperate will search for "X near me" and if you have the most dots it will resolve to you. This means more panicked buyers which directly translates to way more money. — gravypod, 2021-08
It's rampant. Locksmiths, appliance repairs, flowers, you name it. Unfortunately, I have not had similar luck in reporting obviously fake businesses. [VIDEO] — richbell, 2024-01
CBC's Marketplace did an investigation about this years ago. [VIDEO] TL;DW: this is widespread in most cities in Canada. Scammers just setup fake businesses on google to have your nearest locksmith be some generic chain. I would expect this to be the same for the US. — acatton, 2023-02

Related videos