The Wrong Way to Set Speed Limits [ST06]
Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:11:08 · Published:2021-09-06 · Views:2101460
Summary
Not Just Bikes explains how North American speed limits are set and why posted limits matter far less than street design. It argues that drivers follow the road's cues, so safe speeds have to be built into the street.
Why HN recommends it
Recommended again and again in traffic-safety threads as an eye-opener on road design versus posted limits and driver behavior.
it really opened my eyes on the relationship between rules and actual behavior. — HN, 2023
Transit, cities & urban planning
Subtitles (excerpt)
Have you ever been driving down a street and seen a speed limit that just doesn’t make sense. Why is the speed limit 40 here? Should it be? And should this street also be 40? Who decides this stuff and how? The historical way of setting speed limits, and the method still used in most places in North America, is the 85th percentile rule. This rule states that you build a road, call your lowest paid engineering intern, and send them out with a radar gun and a clipboard to record the speeds of drivers during a time of good weather and good visibility. Then you throw away the top 15% of speeds and the highest speed left is rounded down and that becomes your new speed limit. This approach seems reasonable. Until you think about it at all. This method means that 15% of all drivers are breaking the speed limit. So why the 85th percentile? Why not 90%? Or any other number? Or why not just fire the intern and make shit up? But the bigger issue with the 85th percentile is that, like most things wrong with American traffic engineering, it’s a 1960s metric designed for use on rural roads, that was then applied to everything, from highways to city streets, and everything in-between. To understand the problem better, It’s useful
On Hacker News
Europe has a lot more roads with a lower design speed. Curves, narrow lanes, on-street parking, trees/poles/etc close to the road. These things cause people to drive slower, because it doesn't feel safe to go fast. In North America, roads are usually built in the complete opposite way, with long straight roads and wide lanes, so the design speed is actually quite high -- even if that wasn't the i… — gregmac, 2024-05
Not much but it’s a start. Unfortunately the US treats every street and road like it’s a country road when it comes to speed limits, with a lot of deaths as a result. Great video on this at [VIDEO] — CalRobert, 2024-05
> MUTCD designs streets similarly to rural highways, and this can create conditions where people speed when they need to be driving slowly, because the design of the street doesn't reflect the speed the sign says you need to be driving. Not Just Bikes covers this shortfall in a video on speed limits[1], and it really opened my eyes on the relationship between rules and actual behavior. Essentiall… — noirdujour, 2023-01
I think my first intro to this was from a Not Just Bikes video on speed limits [1], and that profoundly affected my opinion on this stuff. I now think a lot of road design is just utterly broken, and it includes speed limits, what that channel (and other related) refer to as "stroads", and intersections (roundabouts vs traffic lights). That video in particular is highly relevant to the speed came… — gregmac, 2022-03
The road design is what causes bad or good driving. The road you describe should narrow before the blind curve so the drivers would (often enough unconsciously) slow down before it. For the pedestrian crossing, small islands that separate the lanes and give pedestrians a safe space will help. [VIDEO] — TomK32, 2025-01
Related videos
- Why We Won't Raise Our Kids in Suburbia · Not Just Bikes · 12:13
- All the Numbers - Numberphile · Numberphile · 14:26
- 4.5 Billion Years in 1 Hour · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 1:03:31
- How to Move the Sun: Stellar Engines · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 8:38
- Throwing Good Money After Bad Car Infrastructure - Wonderland Road · Not Just Bikes · 11:07
- How to (Quickly) Build a Cycling City - Paris · Not Just Bikes · 13:00
- Why don't Americans use electric kettles? · Technology Connections · 24:55
- iPhone 1 - Steve Jobs MacWorld keynote in 2007 - Full Presentation, 80 mins · Protectstar Inc. · 1:19:10
- A Complete Beginner's Guide to Electric Vehicles · Technology Connections · 57:49
- golden balls. the weirdest split or steal ever! · spinout3 · 6:25
- Safe Cycling Showdown - Good vs. Bad City Design - Plus 1 Minus 2 · Not Just Bikes · 23:01
- Why does light slow down in water? · Fermilab · 10:24
- Pig Butchering Scams: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO) · LastWeekTonight · 24:27
- I Misunderstood the Greenhouse Effect. Here's How It Works. · Sabine Hossenfelder · 19:07
- How Self-Driving Cars will Destroy Cities (and what to do about it) · Not Just Bikes · 54:37
- How The Dutch Economy Shows We Can't Reduce Wealth Inequality With Taxes | Economics Explained · Economics Explained · 16:34
- Ben Marking's Fake BBC Nuclear Attack Broadcast (Full Resolution, Uncut, Unedited) · Tooth · 55:42
- The Dumbest Excuse for Bad Cities · Not Just Bikes · 12:59
- The Gym of Life · Not Just Bikes · 11:47
- The Best-Designed Town in the Netherlands (and therefore, the world) · Not Just Bikes · 25:04